Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Pre-Decimal Coins => Topic started by: sirfry on November 14, 2012, 09:10:11 PM

Title: Investment Coins
Post by: sirfry on November 14, 2012, 09:10:11 PM
Hi all. I was interested if anyone has had any good stories or advice about coins as an investment. I have considered buying some sort of decent coin to hang on to for some years but I'm a bit hesitant to part with the cash before I get a bit more experience. Having an 'investment' seems like a good way to justify having really nice (expensive) coins :D I would definitely like to hear from you pros out there that have had any good or bad experiences. :)



There are some nice Sovereigns that I've around that aren't priced too crazy that I've looked at.
(http://www.jaggards.com.au/shop/images/big/BC2402.jpg)
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: gnome on November 14, 2012, 09:16:46 PM
I've been contemplating the same thing for awhile myself, and have been hesitant for exactly the same reason, not wanting to part with alot of my hard earned.
My thoughts have been towards a nice 23 1/2d or a predecimal proof set.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: sirfry on November 14, 2012, 09:37:19 PM
Yeh they look pretty sweet as well. A decent condition 1923 half penny seems to be quite a step up price wise though right?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 14, 2012, 09:50:38 PM
As a rule of thumb "Investing" in coins is not the best use of your investment funds.
At the moment I would consider investing it "Physical" gold or silver a wise investment.
The biggest return you will get for investing in coins is personal satisfaction and enjoyment that in itself is a fantastic return in my books.
If you buy wisely you won't loose any money but you won’t become a millionaire overnight either.
Coins are only worth what people are prepared to pay for them and if the economy turns bad nobody will be able to afford the luxury of collecting coins.

Having said all this in "The long run" coins WILL appreciate in value and the enjoyment you will get out of them is priceless
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: AaronG on November 14, 2012, 10:31:15 PM
I would say physical gold or silver as trout stated. This is because I see coins as more of a hobby. How about trying pre decimal florins or shillings? Even round 50 cent pieces. That's for silver. For gold i'd look into sovereigns! Then of course there is the option to buy bars.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: enworb on November 14, 2012, 11:42:58 PM
I like the predecimal proofs not that i own any at the moment. There are so few of them and if you can get nice ones that arent marked or tonedi would expect them to appreciate over time. They arent particularly expensive either.

My collection is for fun rather than investment though. Like trout said ive gained much more enjoyment from coins that i ever could monetary reward. You would have to pay me a lot of money to get me to give up collecting.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 15, 2012, 07:27:48 AM
I think you need to learn to love coins and collecting them before you can even think about investing in them.  But if you do insist on trying to buy for investment the old adage is to buy the absolute best you can afford in the best grade you can afford.  Even then you'll probably still lose money.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Ozcoins on November 15, 2012, 07:52:53 AM
I think investing in coins is a lot like investing in shares.
It is a gamble that can be helped by knowledge.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: sirfry on November 15, 2012, 08:32:00 AM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='3155' dateline='1352926668'I think you need to learn to love coins and collecting them before you can even think about investing in them.  But if you do insist on trying to buy for investment the old adage is to buy the absolute best you can afford in the best grade you can afford.  Even then you'll probably still lose money.

Don't get me wrong. I do love collecting coins, I just feel that if I bought an expensive coin now even if I loved the coin itself, I would still feel kinda bad if its value plunged dramatically. Obviously there are factors like the economy and demand and so forth that I could never really predict but it would be nice to have a little assurance that over the long term that it wasn't going to become worthless (although possible :) )
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: keldaw on November 15, 2012, 08:38:22 AM
:yahoo:

 look for enjoyment in coins ,, not profits ,..

 only a few coins make it in todays market ..

         good advice ..                          ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 15, 2012, 08:41:19 AM
Quote from: 'sirfry' pid='3162' dateline='1352930520'Don't get me wrong. I do love collecting coins, I just feel that if I bought an expensive coin now even if I loved the coin itself, I would still feel kinda bad if its value plunged dramatically. Obviously there are factors like the economy and demand and so forth that I could never really predict but it would be nice to have a little assurance that over the long term that it wasn't going to become worthless (although possible :) )

If you love collecting coins then you're probably like me and research the heck out of a coin / series before you put any money into it.  You'll probably know important things like:

[list=1]

If you can answer all of these questions then you'll know whether you're likely to be making a good buy or not.  If you can't answer them then it's a crapshoot and you're just buying a coin because you like it.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: sirfry on November 15, 2012, 08:56:03 AM
Thanks markn

Good advice
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: AaronG on November 15, 2012, 09:00:29 AM
Great advice Markn, I like that method :D
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 15, 2012, 09:19:21 AM
When I see a coin I will look into all those points.
But in reality I will ignore them if I want a particular coin for my collection
I have often paid more than market value for a coin I want, So that would make me a lousy investor.
Sometimes I buy bulk lots of pre decimal silver and "noodle" them with some success.
In another few decades my collection WILL be worth more than I paid for it, At the moment NOT A CHANCE.
I really don't care; I collect purely for my own pleasure.
Anyway what’s wrong with a good old crap shoot :dance2:
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: wwwww on November 15, 2012, 10:50:02 AM
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='3157' dateline='1352928173'I think investing in coins is a lot like investing in shares.
It is a gamble that can be helped by knowledge.

I agree, if you take the time to learn about coins and to understand the market, there certainly is a money to be made investing in coins. If you just throw money at the market and hope for the best, you will more than likely lose.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Russ e on November 15, 2012, 05:01:29 PM
low mintage pre decimal silver is what i hope to make the most return from in all my coins, as long as i buy close to or below spot i cant see how i can lose.
if i hade 5k to invest i would grab 2oz of gold and a few nice ( top grade ) coins if there is any change after that more silver low mintage coins.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Cruzi on November 16, 2012, 03:02:26 PM
Quote from: 'Russ e' pid='3195' dateline='1352961089'low mintage pre decimal silver is what i hope to make the most return from in all my coins, as long as i buy close to or below spot i cant see how i can lose.
if i hade 5k to invest i would grab 2oz of gold and a few nice ( top grade ) coins if there is any change after that more silver low mintage coins.

Gold (ETA:and silver) bandwagon left station years ago, buy bullion as a hedge but downside is bigger than upside if investing.

Mintage is not everything, take the 1927 Florins,  plain and Canberra versions both had similar mintage, Canberra got hoarded and is cheap in high grades, plain one did not and is very hard and expensive to find in high grade.

Also be aware hoard discoveries can devalue your coin, 1927P sovs come to mind.

As always, not against investing, just ensuring you make informed choices.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: gnome on November 16, 2012, 11:25:22 PM
Yeah a nice proof sov  probably couldn't hurt either, just as an after thought.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: MobOfRoos on November 17, 2012, 10:21:10 AM
I guess the thing to remember with investing in coins is that they are definitely a [undefined=undefined]long term[/undefined] investment. I have seem many cases of a person buying a coin retail and then selling it a few years later at auction at a huge loss. There are costs involved with buying and selling coins whether it be the 16.5% buyers premium at auctions or the coin dealers retail margins.

My advice would be

- never buy an investment coin retail
- choose a key date coin in the highest grade you can afford
- make sure you wont be needing to sell that coin for at least 20 years

For me the long term question about the future of coin collecting is - will the next generation have the same passion for coin collecting given that they pay for everything with plastic cards now?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: keldaw on November 17, 2012, 06:06:44 PM
Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3339' dateline='1353109870'I guess the thing to remember with investing in coins is that they are definitely a [undefined=undefined]long term[/undefined] investment. I have seem many cases of a person buying a coin retail and then selling it a few years later at auction at a huge loss. There are costs involved with buying and selling coins whether it be the 16.5% buyers premium at auctions or the coin dealers retail margins.

My advice would be

- never buy an investment coin retail
- choose a key date coin in the highest grade you can afford
- make sure you wont be needing to sell that coin for at least 20 years

For me the long term question about the future of coin collecting is - will the next generation have the same passion for coin collecting given that they pay for everything with plastic cards now?


mor , you have the word undefined twice in your post , every time i try to do a post on this forum that word is the only word that shows up ,. do you know what that means please ,...     ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Nevol on November 17, 2012, 06:44:03 PM
Quote from: 'keldaw' pid='3375' dateline='1353137804'[undefined=undefined]long term[/undefined]
mor , you have the word undefined twice in your post , every time i try to do a post on this forum that word is the only word that shows up ,. do you know what that means please ,...     ,, kel ,,[/quote]
This is what happens when someone tries to format part of their post, such as bold, underline, colour etc. The formatting of text doesn't work without a lot of input from the poster.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: keldaw on November 18, 2012, 08:12:26 AM
Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='3377' dateline='1353140043'
Quote from: 'keldaw' pid='3375' dateline='1353137804'[undefined=undefined]long term[/undefined]
mor , you have the word undefined twice in your post , every time i try to do a post on this forum that word is the only word that shows up ,. do you know what that means please ,...     ,, kel ,,
This is what happens when someone tries to format part of their post, such as bold, underline, colour etc. The formatting of text doesn't work without a lot of input from the poster.
[/quote]

thanks nancy , maybe it was me i must have hit the wrong button or something ..        ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: drakesterling on November 19, 2012, 10:54:07 PM
Like OzCoins said, knowledge will help improve the odds of making a dime in this game. To that end, I stumbled on an old grading guide that I had written in 2006! Follow the link and you can download it there:
http://www.drakesterling.com/coins-for-sale/news-feed/news-feed/free-download-of-my-sovereign-grading-guide

Money can certainly be made in the coin business - as it can be in the diamond, art, wine, and antiques businesses. It just boils down to knowledge and research. And sometimes the best knowledge comes from actually buying coins and asking fellow collectors what they think of them. You'll get burned every now and then, but it's all part of the education.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 20, 2012, 12:02:31 AM
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='3555' dateline='1353327847'Like OzCoins said, knowledge will help improve the odds of making a dime in this game. To that end, I stumbled on an old grading guide that I had written in 2006! Follow the link and you can download it there:
http://www.drakesterling.com/coins-for-sale/news-feed/news-feed/free-download-of-my-sovereign-grading-guide

Money can certainly be made in the coin business - as it can be in the diamond, art, wine, and antiques businesses. It just boils down to knowledge and research. And sometimes the best knowledge comes from actually buying coins and asking fellow collectors what they think of them. You'll get burned every now and then, but it's all part of the education.

I consider that learning how to accurately grade a coin is by far the most important step if you want to invest and make a few quid out of coins.
If you haven't got the skill to grade a coin then you are in the dark when it comes to investing in them.
The rule of thumb is the higher the grade the more investment potential the coin has.
The easiest way to get this education is to get some coins in various grades from highly reputable dealers (if you can't do this PCGS will do) and look at them long and hard to work out "Why" they are assigned a certain grade.
You can then use these coins and knowlage as a point of reference when deciding what to pay for your "investment coin" That way you should KNOW what you are buying.

This is only step 1 there are other factors that make a coin "special" and a worthwhile investment.
There is collect ability, rarity and that X Factor some coins have.

Personally I would hate to make my living out of dealing in coins because it would break my heart to sell the nice ones.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Cruzi on November 21, 2012, 09:02:06 AM
Quote from: 'gnome' pid='3318' dateline='1353070522'Yeah a nice proof sov  probably couldn't hurt either, just as an after thought.

*Waves Hand*

Those are not the sovereigns you are looking for.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: stevo1962 on November 21, 2012, 11:50:17 AM
QuoteI consider that learning how to accurately grade a coin is by far the most important step if you want to invest and make a few quid out of coins.
If you haven't got the skill to grade a coin then you are in the dark when it comes to investing in them.
The rule of thumb is the higher the grade the more investment potential the coin has.
The easiest way to get this education is to get some coins in various grades from highly reputable dealers (if you can't do this PCGS will do) and look at them long and hard to work out "Why" they are assigned a certain grade.
You can then use these coins and knowlage as a point of reference when deciding what to pay for your "investment coin" That way you should KNOW what you are buying.

This is only step 1 there are other factors that make a coin "special" and a worthwhile investment.
There is collect ability, rarity and that X Factor some coins have.

Personally I would hate to make my living out of dealing in coins because it would break my heart to sell the nice ones.
 

 Excellent advice trout  -  I couldn't have said it better myself
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: AaronG on November 21, 2012, 12:03:11 PM
Trout what other steps do you believe you need to look at?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Australian coin on November 21, 2012, 01:04:51 PM
I always go by what appeals to me, but I ask myself about the mintage and price of a coin too, before forking out the $$$

There are two types of coin categories, coins that I will probably flip fast and the keepers that will be around for a few years.

You can always ask people here first about a coin, others opinions can help make the right decision for you, at lest you can weigh up the good and bad.

Although I am happy as a pig in muck to stay with collecting circulation coins, after all they only cost you face value, and if you don’t like it you can just spend it.

With investing in coins, to make money is always going to be hit and miss as you can never tell if the coin you are going to buy is going to worth more when the time comes to let it go.

Although some coins are yearly profit makers but it is a case of you have to get in fast and have the money to spend at the time, these coins are certain, silver / gold coins. And they normally require knowing coin dealers to get them as numbers are extremely limited.

An example is the 1kg coins from PM
I held one once a coin show, that’s the closest ill ever get to one!
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: JeffH on November 21, 2012, 02:25:40 PM
I think the golden rule with buying a coin is only buy a coin you like and want to have.
By all means consider investment possibility. But, to buy only as possible investment is a good way to get burnt.

Go for the best condition, scarce coins you can find if considering possible, future value. They are likely to appreciate faster than poorer grade, more common coins.

It is important you know about the coins you buy; hence my golden rule -you are more likely to learn more about the coins that you fancy than coins that are purely investments.

[Hindsight is a wonderful tool for assessing investment possibility. But, you then also need a time machine to profitably put it into practice. :dontknow:]

A good suggestion for any speculative investment (not just coins) is only invest as much as you can afford to lose.

Jeff
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: MobOfRoos on November 22, 2012, 11:04:24 AM
The way I see it there are also different types of investments you can do, and just like any other investment, higher returns mean higher risk.

1) You could buy a nice solid 1930 Penny (or 1923 Half Penny or 1932 Florin) at auction and you would be pretty much guaranteed to make a reasonable investment return.

2) you could do the highly speculative Perth Mint "pass the hand grenade". Where you buy a low mintage Perth Mint release and sell it on the secondary market almost immediately. Members on the CCF forum have been spruiking this method of investment. To me it is just like a pyramid scheme and eventually someone is going to be caught holding a coin which is worth nothing more than bullion.

3) Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.

4) Gold and Silver coins. Unless you buy these coins on the secondary market for bullion value you will be paying the various Mints such a huge premium that they will be useless as an investment. In the end they are mostly affected by the gold and silver price so arn't really a numismatic investment.

It is also important to remember that a coin's value is not just a function of its scarcity. It is also a function of its desirability. So the perfect investment coin would be one that is scarce and would become more desirable as time goes on.

These are just my thoughts on the subject anyway
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: AaronG on November 22, 2012, 12:29:14 PM
MobOfRoos, how much does a coin cost to get graded? Which company is best for Aussie coins?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 22, 2012, 12:48:28 PM
Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'The way I see it there are also different types of investments you can do, and just like any other investment, higher returns mean higher risk.

1) You could buy a nice solid 1930 Penny (or 1923 Half Penny or 1932 Florin) at auction and you would be pretty much guaranteed to make a reasonable investment return.

I disagree.  1930 pennies and 1923 half pennies are selling (a lot) less than what they were 5 years ago in common grades.  There's absolutely no guarantee you'll make money out of these.  They are always available and regardless of the mintages not scarce on the market.  To stand a much better chance of making money from them you need to buy as high a grade as possible.  If that grade is run-of-the-mill and commonly available then you're much more likely to lose money.

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'3) Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.

Again disagree.  There's no risk if you know how TPG's grade and what they are looking for to get high numbers. And you can pick a coin that they won't call cleaned, rim-damaged, planchet-flawed, tooled or any other number of things that a lot of Australian dealers do not disclose.  And you can actually find a coin that's worth getting graded and do so without spending an inordinately large amount of time to make it worth the effort.  All of those sound like risks to me.  If you think it's so easy why are there so many rubbish coins in PCGS slabs on eBay right now?  That's because it's not easy and it's not a sure-fire method to do anything.

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'It is also important to remember that a coin's value is not just a function of its scarcity. It is also a function of its desirability. So the perfect investment coin would be one that is scarce and would become more desirable as time goes on.

Agree completely.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: MobOfRoos on November 22, 2012, 12:52:35 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='3737' dateline='1353550708'I disagree.  1930 pennies and 1923 half pennies are selling (a lot) less than what they were 5 years ago in common grades.

Agreed. I was thinking more long term. Getting an investment return over 5 years on any coin would be speculative at best. Especially with the selling and buying costs factored in.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 22, 2012, 01:13:00 PM
Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3739' dateline='1353550955'Agreed. I was thinking more long term. Getting an investment return over 5 years on any coin would be speculative at best. Especially with the selling and buying costs factored in.

I think some people who bought 1930 pennies in the early to mid 2000's when the market was near it's peak won't see a positive ROI for 30+ years when you take inflation into account.  If ever.  They'd certainly have done a lot better leaving their money in a fixed-term account and rolling it over annually.  You are perfectly correct in your long-term outlook.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: gnome on November 22, 2012, 01:18:44 PM
Getting away from just the coins as an investment I purchased an  unc 1967 $10 note some years ago. It seems to be doing ok.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 22, 2012, 01:19:59 PM
Quote from: 'gnome' pid='3742' dateline='1353552524'Getting away from just the coins as an investment I purchased an  unc 1967 $10 note some years ago. It seems to be doing ok.

Nice :yahoo:
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Cruzi on November 22, 2012, 02:32:07 PM
The single biggest mistake I see and it is not just coins, is that people do not understand buy low, sell high.

The common interpretation is buy high, hoping to sell higher.

A couple of common examples in recent times, Telstra 2 float, most buyers thought they were on a sure bet like the first float & gold, time to buy was over a decade ago when it had been sitting at a plateau for over a decade.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing but do not ignore it, see how markets have behaved in the past and apply those tools to now.  

Market forces always overshoot, they will jump from undervalued to overvalued back down to undervalued ad infinitum
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 22, 2012, 04:26:52 PM
Quote from: 'Cruzi' pid='3745' dateline='1353556927'The single biggest mistake I see and it is not just coins, is that people do not understand buy low, sell high.

Cruzi has hit the nail on my coin investing head here.  I am by no means an investor but the best returns BY FAR on any coins I've got were in the buying.  I saw something that was mis-identified, conservatively graded, or was just a plain bargain and I knew it was a bargain.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Fr45h3R on November 22, 2012, 06:23:50 PM
What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.
For those only concerned about 'returns' (eg: self managed super funds) it frightens me to think what position some people may be in when it is time to realise the value of these investments.
Type 'self managed super investment coins' into Google, and see what comes up.
Even better, search for 'investment' in Australian coins on eBay.

I was poking around in this space about 10 months ago, but my pocket is glad I've found forums like this and fellow enthusiasts like you guys.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: markn on November 22, 2012, 06:47:26 PM
Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.
For those only concerned about 'returns' (eg: self managed super funds) it frightens me to think what position some people may be in when it is time to realise the value of these investments.
Type 'self managed super investment coins' into Google, and see what comes up.
Even better, search for 'investment' in Australian coins on eBay.

I was poking around in this space about 10 months ago, but my pocket is glad I've found forums like this and fellow enthusiasts like you guys.

I've done well on some coins but I am not ashamed to say that the vast majority of my coins (90% or more) I probably haven't made a cent on.  And in most cases I've lost money on them.  I own those coins because they are cool and I love having them.  Investment be darned, collecting coins is too much tooting fun :)
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Mister T on November 22, 2012, 08:36:29 PM
Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.

Do you mean the claims of 1000% increases that don't account for inflation?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Cruzi on November 23, 2012, 10:05:53 AM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='3753' dateline='1353572246'I've done well on some coins but I am not ashamed to say that the vast majority of my coins (90% or more) I probably haven't made a cent on.  And in most cases I've lost money on them.  I own those coins because they are cool and I love having them.  Investment be darned, collecting coins is too much tooting fun :)

I've been lucky and managed to make a bit as well, thing is, had to be brutal about it, sentiment had no place, that is why I have a coin collection and, as part of a larger investment strategy, some investment coins.

Coins like the Australians At War kookas are never going to give me a profit but the pleasure they give is priceless.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: wwwww on November 23, 2012, 02:08:28 PM
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3757' dateline='1353578789'
Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.

Do you mean the claims of 1000% increases that don't account for inflation?

They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

Quote3) Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.

Where can I buy these high grade, risk free coins?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Mister T on November 23, 2012, 02:46:38 PM
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3797' dateline='1353641908'They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

I don't understand.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: wwwww on November 24, 2012, 09:29:19 AM
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3798' dateline='1353644198'
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3797' dateline='1353641908'They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

I don't understand.

Percentage return figures don't ever factor in inflation. Why then should you factor it in for coins?

Take for example, a number of ways of investing money:

A particular apartment appreciated by 3% pa in value and had a net rental return of 3% pa, so a total of 6% profit.

A bank term deposit paid 6% pa.

A particular coin appreciated by 8% pa, but there was 4% inflation, and you have to factor it in as you say, so it really only appreciated by 4% pa.

So the coin made a 4% return pa, the other two options paid 6%, yet the coin had the most return, how is that possible?
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 24, 2012, 10:13:20 AM
Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.
 
Where can I buy these high grade, risk free coins?

A lot of us can and do find some exceptional coins at bargain basement prices.

It isn't easy and it doesn’t happen too obtain but it can be done.

I would imagine getting a high value coin certified will improve the saleability/price of a coin but you would have to justify the costs (about $50 per coin) of slabbing a coin for sale.

It is amazing how many "Run of the Mill" coins are slabbed these days
And the ONLY thing inflating the price of these is the sellers adding the cost of the slabbing to the otherwise low value coins.

In theory is IS possible to find high value coins at low cost and get them certified to make a profit on them But in practice this is quite a rare occurrence.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: MobOfRoos on November 24, 2012, 10:24:37 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='3815' dateline='1353714200'It is amazing how many "Run of the Mill" coins are slabbed these days


We all saw that AU55 1946 Penny going for an absurd price

http://www.australian-coins.net/showthread.php?tid=242&highlight=1946

but I'll stop :dead_horse:

Walter is right about factoring in inflation. It is something we have to do ourselves to decide whether it is a good investment or not.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Mister T on November 24, 2012, 11:40:36 AM
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3812' dateline='1353711559'Percentage return figures don't ever factor in inflation. Why then should you factor it in for coins?

Take for example, a number of ways of investing money:

A particular apartment appreciated by 3% pa in value and had a net rental return of 3% pa, so a total of 6% profit.

A bank term deposit paid 6% pa.

A particular coin appreciated by 8% pa, but there was 4% inflation, and you have to factor it in as you say, so it really only appreciated by 4% pa.

So the coin made a 4% return pa, the other two options paid 6%, yet the coin had the most return, how is that possible?

Yeah okay I get what you're saying.
I don't think it's totally correct to just do a straight percentage growth calculation on a $400 1930 penny in 1966 and an $18000 1930 penny today though as it may not be clear to everyone that inflation played a part in the increased dollar value. I don't know if there's a better way of representing such information though. In that example there would have been potential for investment as such a 1930 penny would be worth more now even with inflation but it doesn't tell the full story.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 24, 2012, 11:50:22 AM
Yeah okay I get what you're saying.
 I don't think it's totally correct to just do a straight percentage growth calculation on a $400 1930 penny in 1966 and an $18000 1930 penny today though as it may not be clear to everyone that inflation played a part in the increased dollar value. I don't know if there's a better way of representing such information though. In that example there would have been potential for investment as such a 1930 penny would be worth more now even with inflation but it doesn't tell the full story.

The "Collectabillity Factor" on certain coins in my opinion is the biggest factor to consider.
Also the hobby may have grown over the last couple of decades and there are more collectors out there that want the coins.
All the "Low Mintage  " coins will become scarce as more collectors get into this hobby especialy in the top grades.

All you have to do is work out which coins are going to be the "Must Have" for newer collectors :good:
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: Fr45h3R on November 24, 2012, 01:31:01 PM
QuoteDo you mean the claims of 1000% increases that don't account for inflation?
I think just these claims in general are cause for concern.
The numbers may be correct but to the uneducated it makes it sound so easy to make the big dollars. It will always be a case of buyer beware.

QuoteIt is amazing how many "Run of the Mill" coins are slabbed these days
One thing to remember is that any pre-decimal coin these days, is over 50 years old give or take a few years, and have been out of circulation for around this period as well. Whilst the occasional roll or hoard may surface, even so called "run of the mill" coins may be quite difficult to acquire in true uncirculated and original condition.

QuoteIn theory is IS possible to find high value coins at low cost and get them certified to make a profit on them But in practice this is quite a rare occurrence.
From the open market like ebay it can be done. But i think the losses balance out any wins quite quickly.
And even wins may become losses, for example if the coins achieves a 'details' grade from third party grading.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: wwwww on November 24, 2012, 01:45:57 PM
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3823' dateline='1353719436'
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3812' dateline='1353711559'Percentage return figures don't ever factor in inflation. Why then should you factor it in for coins?

Take for example, a number of ways of investing money:

A particular apartment appreciated by 3% pa in value and had a net rental return of 3% pa, so a total of 6% profit.

A bank term deposit paid 6% pa.

A particular coin appreciated by 8% pa, but there was 4% inflation, and you have to factor it in as you say, so it really only appreciated by 4% pa.

So the coin made a 4% return pa, the other two options paid 6%, yet the coin had the most return, how is that possible?

Yeah okay I get what you're saying.
I don't think it's totally correct to just do a straight percentage growth calculation on a $400 1930 penny in 1966 and an $18000 1930 penny today though as it may not be clear to everyone that inflation played a part in the increased dollar value. I don't know if there's a better way of representing such information though. In that example there would have been potential for investment as such a 1930 penny would be worth more now even with inflation but it doesn't tell the full story.

Your figures are measured in dollars, so your growth must be measured against dollars, i.e. your 1930 penny appreciated to 4500% against the AUD over 46 years, or 20% pa. It is unreasonable and to some degree deceptive to measure growth against anything other than what the figures are quoted in.

If your figures are measured by other means, then it is reasonable to to measure growth by those means. E.g. if you say the 1930 penny was worth 3 weeks of average wages in Australia, and now it is worth 12 weeks, therefore it appreciated 3% pa against the average Australian income over the past 46 years.

Neither statement is more reasonable than the other, but saying it went from $400 to $18000, therefore the growth was 3% pa would be deceptive.

Remember every value is measured relative to something else. If you valued the growth of the 1930 penny against the Zimbabwe dollar, then it grew many million percent but if you measure it against gold, then it went down. When you factor in inflation, you're really measuring performance against the index which your inflation figure is drawn from.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 26, 2012, 01:31:51 PM
This arrived today for a total cost of $16.52.
[attachment=487][attachment=488]
[attachment=489][attachment=490]
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: drakesterling on November 26, 2012, 05:47:13 PM
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3823' dateline='1353719436'Yeah okay I get what you're saying.
I don't think it's totally correct to just do a straight percentage growth calculation on a $400 1930 penny in 1966 and an $18000 1930 penny today though as it may not be clear to everyone that inflation played a part in the increased dollar value. I don't know if there's a better way of representing such information though. In that example there would have been potential for investment as such a 1930 penny would be worth more now even with inflation but it doesn't tell the full story.

The simplest way to compare returns is using "CAGR" - or compound annual growth rate. Most investments in the investment world are measured with this metric, so an annual return in coins of a certain amount can be compared (more or less) to the same figure in equities, real estate, and so on.

CAGR is a measure of average annual growth in an investments price, taking into account the fact that last year’s return will add to the return of this year, which will add to the return next year, and so on. There are websites that explain this far better than I can.

Ignore inflation. If you factor inflation into your calculation, then you can’t compare your calculation with the returns of other asset classes (which don’t factor inflation). There are other reasons why inflation is not factored, but we don’t need to get into them here.

So, using your 1930 penny example: If it was worth $400 in 1966 and you could realise $18k for it 46 years later in 2012, then the annual return is 8.6%pa compounded annually. This says that your coin appreciated in value on average 8.6% each year in the last 46 years.

Now, if you compare 8.6% to the return of bank deposits, equities, real estate, gold, and other investments over that time, you can compare how this particular coin has performed against these other investments. For example, banks are paying interest around 4 - 5%pa at the moment.

I'm sorry to make this complicated, but doing the calculation is the most effective and (more importantly) comparable way to calculate returns in coins.
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: trout on November 26, 2012, 05:58:17 PM
There have been all sorts of comparisons with gold, silver, real estate etc and all sorts of formulas.
Who really gives a rats, at the end of the day if your coin can match or better inflation then it is a far better investment than leaving cash in the bank.
If you buy a coin and just leave it alone, Most times it will at least keep up with inflation.
I guarantee you if you leave cash in the bank for a long period of time and leave it alone it will dwindle away to nothing due to bank charges etc
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: wwwww on November 27, 2012, 08:12:56 AM
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='3915' dateline='1353914233'So, using your 1930 penny example: If it was worth $400 in 1966 and you could realise $18k for it 46 years later in 2012, then the annual return is 8.6%pa compounded annually. This says that your coin appreciated in value on average 8.6% each year in the last 46 years.

You're right, how on earth did I get 20%?

For everyone's information, the calculation is 18000/400 for the total % increase (4500%). Then to convert that to an annual compounded increase, put it to the power of 1/years. So 45^(1/46) = 1.0862 which is the increase per year, or 8.62%
Title: RE: Investment Coins
Post by: stevo1962 on January 03, 2013, 12:10:04 PM
One method I use to collect high grade coins at lower prices is to buy from outside Australia (mostly from UK and USA) as there is less competition and occasionally picking up good raw coins for 1/2 and sometimes 1/4 of the price that I could buy them in Australia for.Slabbed coins generally cost a bit more but the bargains are out there and with the USA hanging over the fiscal cliff there are likely to be more of these bargains coming out of the woodwork although if you look hard enough there are still plenty of bargains to be had in Australia but it takes time to find them