Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Decimal Circulating Coins => Topic started by: Raritiescoinlover on June 07, 2014, 05:03:17 PM

Title: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Raritiescoinlover on June 07, 2014, 05:03:17 PM
I would like to say hi to everyone in this forum and here is a piece of the Australia 1966 Queen elizabeth II 50 cents silver coin which is in brilliant uncirculated condition.The coin is with natural original shade which has no toning,no black spots and no scatches on both sides surface.The piece is with shining luster surface and the most beautiful silver coin from my personal coin collection to be honest with you.I would think the coin which has tremendous high grade with high rating number because of the shining luster shade.The opinion require.Please check it out on the scans below and let me know what you think there.Thank you


(http://s25.postimg.org/qs8w4107j/1275.jpg)
(http://s25.postimg.org/jqayhtwlr/1276.jpg)
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: serial on June 07, 2014, 05:31:49 PM
I see to many knocks and breaks in lustre to go any higher than ms 63 so sorry its not B-Unc in my opinion
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: trout on June 07, 2014, 08:43:09 PM
:welcome:
Raritiescoinlover
I saw this coin on CCF and didn't comment, However now that you are in "my backyard" I will give you my unbiased opinion :ok:

These are treated pretty much as a "Bullion" coin in Australia and anything under MS63 is regarded at melt value.
Your coin regardless of how much you love it would struggle at MS62 unfortunately :ok:
Sorry to burst your bubble on this coin but if you want soft and politically correct answers look to CCF.
If you really want truthful and honest answers then this is the site for you.

So take your boots off, relax  and stick around , because this is the best Aussie coin site on the Planet where bullshit is tolerated but NOT revered :yahoo:
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: proof27 on June 07, 2014, 08:45:46 PM
Quote from: 'serial' pid='51576' dateline='1402128109'I see to many knocks and breaks in lustre to go any higher than ms 63 so sorry its not B-Unc in my opinion

:agreed:
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Raritiescoinlover on June 07, 2014, 11:14:13 PM
Quote from: 'serial' pid='51576' dateline='1402128109'I see to many knocks and breaks in lustre to go any higher than ms 63 so sorry its not B-Unc in my opinion

I would think for your opinion is accurate about the rating number which has low number to receive for the uncirculated condition there.

Quote from: 'trout' pid='51611' dateline='1402139589':welcome:
Raritiescoinlover
I saw this coin on CCF and didn't comment, However now that you are in "my backyard" I will give you my unbiased opinion :ok:

These are treated pretty much as a "Bullion" coin in Australia and anything under MS63 is regarded at melt value.
Your coin regardless of how much you love it would struggle at MS62 unfortunately :ok:
Sorry to burst your bubble on this coin but if you want soft and politically correct answers look to CCF.
If you really want truthful and honest answers then this is the site for you.

So take your boots off, relax  and stick around , because this is the best Aussie coin site on the Planet where bullshit is tolerated but NOT revered :yahoo:

It is nice to hear that you are the viewer on the CCF website and my suggestion right for you should have commented earlier on the website because to receive for more opinion and you are right about it right now.

Quote from: 'proof27' pid='51612' dateline='1402139746'
Quote from: 'serial' pid='51576' dateline='1402128109'I see to many knocks and breaks in lustre to go any higher than ms 63 so sorry its not B-Unc in my opinion

:agreed:

The most interesting for the coin is with the beautiful shining luster which has no toning but it has so many bad marks on obverse side makes lower grade to become normal piece which is unfortunely there.

I have realised for the same opinions about the grade from the other members on difference at forums to say the same grade number which cannot be higher for the grade but someone said its MS68 number there.
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Fordprefect on June 07, 2014, 11:33:36 PM
Welcome to the forum Raritiescoinlover

As the grade for the coin is determined by primarily
the coins surface, this aspect is missing in youe image.

All those imperfections that are showing could well be
defects in the mylar flip.
Remove it and take another shot.

The coin image as presented I can't see it making MS
let alone a high end MS score.
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: serial on June 07, 2014, 11:37:40 PM
"I would think for your opinion is accurate about the rating number which has low number to receive for the uncirculated condition there."
i really wish i understood what you meant by that
if you think it is ms 68 get it graded and i will personally pay your grading fee if it came back as ms 68 the mark on the cheek and below the L in Elizabeth  is enough to down grade it to 65 much less the rest
markn do you have an opinion on this one?
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: trout on June 07, 2014, 11:44:50 PM
Quotemarkn do you have an opinion on this one?
Don't piss him off (that's MY job) :laugh2:
Seriously tho this may be one of the times he will agree with my at best MS62 assessment of this coin :ok:
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: markn on June 08, 2014, 09:22:10 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='51647' dateline='1402150490'
Quotemarkn do you have an opinion on this one?
Don't piss him off (that's MY job) :laugh2:
Seriously tho this may be one of the times he will agree with my at best MS62 assessment of this coin :ok:

AU perhaps, perhaps low MS, hard to make out too much from over exposed images.  Nothing special.  

The OP should learn that "shiny" != "high grade".
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Goldseeker on June 08, 2014, 09:52:24 AM
I have 755 of these 1966 x 50c pieces and many of them look the same as that one pictured.   Even circulated ones look good.

As to the grade, well that is not one of my specialities.

The ones I have will be held for melt value once the price of silver rises once again unless someone desperately some and then I might sell privately but only if the price is right.

I was In  Melbourne during the past week and a lady walked in and sold to the shop owner, 103 of these coins to which she was paid $6.50 each.   Had I been a few minutes earlier, I would have offered $6.75 or even $7 per coin.   Darn it.

When the lady had left the shop, I asked how much for the coins and I was told $8 each.   Not bad profit me thinks.

In saying that, the price of these coins have fallen somewhat over the past months.
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: robbiegal on June 08, 2014, 11:28:06 AM
shop owner might not have been impressed goldie if you snitched that sale ... in their shop
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Coins from Vending on June 08, 2014, 12:18:56 PM
C'mon Shiny with lots of bling is my description
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: serial on June 08, 2014, 01:23:53 PM
I love getting them for face value from the banks
still can be done
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Goldseeker on June 08, 2014, 02:33:57 PM
Agreed Serial, but very rare these days.
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: purplepennyhunter on June 08, 2014, 05:26:22 PM
The grade of MS68 was suggested by CCF member shanew. :dodgy:
Title: RE: Australia 50 cents silver coin tremendous high grade?
Post by: Raritiescoinlover on June 10, 2014, 06:47:08 PM
I would think for the natural original shade and shining luster on the surface is beautiful enough for me compare with most of them with other shade to be honest with you there.Thank you