Hi folks,
I live in England and on the way to work this morning and they were speaking to an a person from Republicanism movement in Australia about how the recent Royal Tour was all propaganda by the Monarchy.
I know the Queen of England is the head of state and according to Wikipedia. Australia is a federal parliamentary constitutional monarchy.
Without debating what Australia should be, I really can't see what impact this actually has and what change is actually wanted.
Can someone please explain?
Thanks,
Ken
Quote from: 'ken-a' pid='47407' dateline='1398426184'Hi folks,
I live in England and on the way to work this morning and they were speaking to an a person from Republicanism movement in Australia about how the recent Royal Tour was all propaganda by the Monarchy.
I know the Queen of England is the head of state and according to Wikipedia. Australia is a federal parliamentary constitutional monarchy.
Without debating what Australia should be, I really can't see what impact this actually has and what change is actually wanted.
Can someone please explain?
Thanks,
Ken
Some people believe the head of state should be an Australian.
Several possible models were proposed a few years ago but it all got bogged down in which model should/could be adopted. This confused people and a referendum for a republic failed.
For all those Australians who would like to see a republic, there are also many Australians who prefer the current system and want it retained.
Today, the republic question has gone off the boil and I don't think there will be any change for the foreseeable future.
hummmm
think I'd prefer HRM on our coins than a Prime Minister who changes , well, sometimes like the wind!
an excerpt from PM Abbot's Anzac speech today with Kate and Wills in company....
He also recognised Australia's relationship with Britain, with the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge nearby.
"Long ago, we ceased to regard Britain as the mother country, but we're still family," Mr Abbott said to Prince William.
"Your presence Sir, reminds us of all our comrades-in-arms."
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/western-front-as-important-as-gallipoli-says-tony-abbott-in-anzac-day-speech-20140425-zqzjb.html#ixzz2zuDQHJZa
There are many ex-pat Poms in Australia and that tends to sway the vote at referendums, especially as the Queen is much loved by most of them. When Charles becomes King, that might be a whole new ball game.
Quote from: 'ken-a' pid='47407' dateline='1398426184'Without debating what Australia should be, I really can't see what impact this actually has and what change is actually wanted.
One peculiarity of the Australian political system is compulsory participation in the electoral process. This means that whenever a referendum is held, it's not just the people who fervently believe either in Yes or No that vote;
everybody has to vote, whether you know about or understand the issue being debated or not. Which means both sides need to come up with simple, easy-to-understand reasons able to convince even the dullest voter.
You have, perhaps unwittingly, tapped into the primary defence used by monarchists whenever the issue comes up for debate: the fear of change. They will typically point to the American-presidential-style political system and say, "Do you really want to risk Australia becoming like
that?"
Or, in other words, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it.".
NOBODY ACTUALLY HAS TO VOTE!
If you are on the electoral roll then you must attend a polling booth and have your name marked off or risk a fine. What you do with the voting papers is then up to you -some bin them and many make a "donkey vote". More's the pity.
Quote from: 'Sapyx' pid='47441' dateline='1398471659'One peculiarity of the Australian political system is compulsory participation in the electoral process. This means that whenever a referendum is held, it's not just the people who fervently believe either in Yes or No that vote; everybody has to vote, whether you know about or understand the issue being debated or not.
Having worked as a Poll Clerk (back in '83) I know that many voters don't understand ANYTHING.
My polling place was my local school, just 2 blocks from one of the biggest asylum complexes for mental inmates. The party hacks would marshal them into the booth and "assist" them in voting. Half of them were drooling idiots who would have voted for Stalin if directed. Even regular folks were not much better, one guy couldn't understand why he couldn't vote for Bob Hawke if he didn't live in his electorate. I'd hate to think of those idiots voting for El Presidente.
At least with Liz, Chuck, Wills and wee Georgie you know what you are getting. With a president they might just elect someone popular only to find out that they have "issues".
I don't think I will ever see this happening in my life time, as much as I think it would be a good thing for all Australians.
No I can't sorry Ken and I don't think anyone knows if it would and what sort of difference it would make if any, maybe save us a little if we send money to the royals but really not sure sorry.
Now a little off track sorry but still on the same subject, well I don't think it will happen while ever they want to elect their own head, the people should do this as we know they can't be trusted and to me it will only lead to a dictatorship or the like the way they want to do it..all referendums are worded to give them the out come they want or it doesn't happen and same with an enquiry as they know what out come they want and another are surveys as it depends on the question and where you ask it as to the out come :)
And Neal has another good point with the voting as that has been going on with nursing homes as well and not to mention the people that vote the way their religious officials or employers tell them :(
I'm with Sap on this one.
If it aint broke then don't fix it makes a whole lot of sense :ok:
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='47433' dateline='1398469222'There are many ex-pat Poms in Australia and that tends to sway the vote at referendums, especially as the Queen is much loved by most of them.
Speaking as an ex-pat Poms one thing we don't love is generalizations about ex-pat Poms. I'm strongly in favor of Australia becoming a republic given a suitable model. I would certainly like the head of state to be a non-political appointment, but the chances of that happening will be small to none.
Splock, I was speaking as an ex-pat Pom too, but maybe I should have said' "many of them", not "most of them".
Thanks for all of the information.
I did not know that voting was required.
Who gets the right to vote? Citizens only?
In the UK, EU citizens and folks from a commonwealth country who have leave to remain can vote.
Sadly, because of incident back in 1776, I can't vote in UK elections.
gee am I the only aussie on here :(
trout wrote, If it aint broke then don't fix it makes a whole lot of sense Ok
:laugh2: well we need fixin pretty bloody bad according to abbot and hockey because isn't the gov broke and that's why they've had all these trips O/S and bringing the royals out at our expense and now buying that many fighter planes that we don't have enough pilots to fly them so I take it we are going to war big time soon or are we becoming more like the US and we'll show them all that we are a war nation now and will assert our authority in the asia pacific on behalf of the US, well they say that they are and that's why they are attacking DSP and other pensions and self funded retirees why everything is goin thru the roof..what is so hard about taxin the rich as even the yanks can do it but we can't or how about cutting back on what the politicians and ex cost us or even middle and upper income where it's been a vote buying exercise from the k/howard times :(
What Splock said is right and why it will never happen as the people won't come at it as we don't like the 'suitable model' that they propose all the time.
No it's not required Ken but once you register on the electoral roll you MUST at least get your name marked off or they fine you :( and I think you have to be an aussie to vote but not really sure on that sorry.
I'm not 100% sure, but you may only need Permanent Resident status, to be allowed to vote.
Quote from: 'ken-a' pid='47487' dateline='1398531523'I did not know that voting was required.
Who gets the right to vote? Citizens only?
In the UK, EU citizens and folks from a commonwealth country who have leave to remain can vote.
According to the Australian Electoral Commission website (http://www.aec.gov.au/enrol/):
QuoteYou are required by law to enrol if you:
- are an Australian citizen, or eligible British subject,
- aged 18 years and over, and
- have lived at your address for at least one month.
"Eligible British subject" is an anachronism from our colonial past: any citizen of Britain or any other British Commonwealth country who had applied to be on the Australian electoral roll prior to 26th January 1984 is, in effect, treated just like an Australian citizen for electoral purposes. Recent immigrants from Britain cannot vote until and unless they become Australian citizens.
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='47444' dateline='1398473596'NOBODY ACTUALLY HAS TO VOTE!
If you are on the electoral roll then you must attend a polling booth and have your name marked off or risk a fine. What you do with the voting papers is then up to you -some bin them and many make a "donkey vote". More's the pity.
It's true that there aren't Voting Police that frogmarch you down to the ballot booth and stand over your shoulder while you vote, making it impossible to refuse to vote. But the triple compulsions (compulsory enrolment on the electoral roll, compulsory attendance at polling booths on election days and compulsory receipt of a ballot paper and subsequent depositing of said ballot paper into a ballot box), combined with various other laws (such as prohibiting the encouragement of informal voting during an election campaign) mean that, for most people most of the time, it is by far the easier thing to do to vote, rather than to find some way of not-voting.
Quote from: 'ken-a' pid='47487' dateline='1398531523'Sadly, because of incident back in 1776, I can't vote in UK elections.
I'm pretty sure that one of the reasons given for the "incident" was that you wouldn't have been allowed to vote in elections
prior to 1776, either. :derisive: