Was on the Strand Coins site the other night and read an interesting piece attached to a 1916 Halfpenny Mule that is currently for sale. The info revolves around a small cud marker that apparently all known Mule coins have. This marker is a small pimple like cud at the inner ring of the reverse above "N" of ONE, and is accompanied by quite a good picture.
Reading further it was said that upon discovery of the incorrect Indian Quarter Anna die, it was obviously substituted with the correct Aussie obverse die. The reverse die was left in place to see out it's useful life and would have been responsible for a mintage of about 30,000.
I got to thinking about this figure of 30,000 which certainly isn't a huge number, and considering the meltdowns in the run up to decimalisation and other forms of natural attrition, I reckon any 1916 halfpenny reverse that displayed this marker would have to be reasonably scarce.
To my surprise the three 1916 coins I have, two are long tail 6 varieties, the other is a normal 6, all display this cud marker at the inner ring above "N". Am I dreaming :yahoo: :angel::yahoo:
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10064/1916_long_tail_6_rev__mule_die_cud.JPG)
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10064/1916_rev__mule_die_cud_at_inner_circle.JPG)
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10064/1916_long_tail_6_rev__mule_die.JPG)
There are TWO flaws on the inner ring. The first is above the N of oNe and a second flaw is above the E of onE.
Now ask yourself, if both the long tail 6 and normal 6 have these 2 markers then they are not a die marker but a hub marker as the long tail 6 would have been from a different working die to the normal 6.
Now if 1916 halves exist without these 2 flaws then that would be due to 3 possible (legitimate) reasons.
1: The early dies were sans these markers as the hub had yet to deteriorate.
2: The late dies were sans these markers as the hub was worked on (unlikely)
3: There were 2 (or more) hubs made.
There is some speculation that some mules are not kosher. Fred Lever mentioned to me a few months back that he thinks at least one sold recently at auction is a fake.
Cool info, put in the memory bank.!! Thankyou.!!
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='43937' dateline='1394865964'There are TWO flaws on the inner ring. The first is above the N of oNe and a second flaw is above the E of onE.
Now ask yourself, if both the long tail 6 and normal 6 have these 2 markers then they are not a die marker but a hub marker as the long tail 6 would have been from a different working die to the normal 6.
Thanks for your take on this as my knowledge of how dies are produced and used is minimal, but can I say, I was always of the belief that the long tailed 6 was due to a broken working die which gave the impression of a lengthened tail. If this was the case, wouldn't it be possible for the same working die to have minted both the long tailed 6 as well as the normal six?