Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: trout on December 27, 2013, 12:48:43 PM

Title: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 12:48:43 PM
Is this die polishing marks or cleaning marks?
The lines appear to be under the lustre and are not on the devices on the coin.
The reverse is mark free.

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/die_poilish2.jpg)


(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/die_poilish1.jpg)


(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/die_poilish.jpg)
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 12:54:49 PM
Die polish.  Good photos Trout.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 12:55:44 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='38214' dateline='1388111089'Die polish.  Good photos Trout.

I cheated and used my usb gizmo:angel:
This is another Canberra florin I am going to send to PCGS and I was a bit concerned about these marks on the coin.
I am SOOO OVA "details' being stamped on my slabs :(
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: purplepennyhunter on December 27, 2013, 12:57:57 PM
Yep die polish. See they stop at the lettering.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 01:08:35 PM
Here is the rest of the coin, yes I know the pics are crap :dash1:

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/dec_canberra1.jpg)

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/dec_canberra.jpg)

I just noticed that my pics ended up coming out black and white on the post but they are actually l colour pics :huh:
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 01:43:17 PM
Jim, what's going on with the bottom half of the reverse of that coin?  Is all that smoosh on the holder or on the coin?
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 01:55:06 PM
It only shows at a certain angle, I think it is the beginning to tone.
The lustre isn't broken but is a different brilliance/shade.
Here are the usb shots of the areas

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/dec_canberra_toning1.jpg)

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/dec_canberra_toning.jpg)
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 02:09:30 PM
It looks like a bad dip.  I wouldn't expect that coin to grade too well.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 02:22:21 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='38225' dateline='1388115570'It looks like a bad dip.  I wouldn't expect that coin to grade too well.

Bugger :dash1::dash1::dash1:
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 02:54:38 PM
I think you are stuck between a rock and a hard place.  Living where you do you're not going to get to see many coins in-hand and in-hand is the only real way of getting a real idea of the quality of a coin.  So you are stuck buying online and that means dealing with sellers images.  It's hard enough to grade from great images, and from poor images it's little more than a gamble.  I very rarely buy 'high grade' coins online anymore unless I know the seller very well.  When I do buy a coin from an online seller I don't know I expect the coin to be awful and I am rarely wrong.  You're going to continue having this problem because you've got no choice but to buy online.  

I am not sure what advice I can offer to give you a better "hit rate" other than being willing to travel to coin shows or to capital cities a few times a year and do your buying there.  Of course if the pleasure for you is in finding a treasure online then keep buying online.  But if you're wanting to buy coins to slab you're going to have to re-think your buying strategy.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: Fulvio on December 27, 2013, 03:05:43 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='38228' dateline='1388118278'I am not sure what advice I can offer to give you a better "hit rate"

How about appointing an agent to act on his behalf? Like, say, you for example? Do it all professionally of course, with a modest agent's fee for the time and trouble.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 03:18:10 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='38230' dateline='1388118943'
Quote from: 'markn' pid='38228' dateline='1388118278'I am not sure what advice I can offer to give you a better "hit rate"

How about appointing an agent to act on his behalf? Like, say, you for example? Do it all professionally of course, with a modest agent's fee for the time and trouble.

I really have no sensible way of answering this.  If Jim wants a particular coin in a given grade then he's welcome to let me know and we'll keep an eye out for it.  But who knows how long it will take and what the "real" cost would be be.  When you see an MS65 parliament florin on the PP website we might have looked at 100-200 coins to find that single coin.  That's a few hours of looking at coins spread over months, plus paperwork, plus submission costs.  Plus PPH and I almost never buy from the "public" so the raw cost of our coins is typically pretty high too.  

So in the end rather than waiting for me to make an MS65 parliament florin for him and passing on the "real cost" he's probably better off just waiting for one to appear on our website and buying it at retail (which will be lower than the "real cost").

I should add to this that I really don't want to know what our "real cost" is.  I am about 99.9% certain that given the number of hours that PPH (and I to a lesser degree) put into the Purple Penny that she'd be better off working at K-Mart or something.  But she enjoys it and it allows us to keep in touch with other collectors.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 03:24:15 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='38230' dateline='1388118943'
Quote from: 'markn' pid='38228' dateline='1388118278'I am not sure what advice I can offer to give you a better "hit rate"

How about appointing an agent to act on his behalf? Like, say, you for example? Do it all professionally of course, with a modest agent's fee for the time and trouble.

Another idea is for Jim to mail his coins to some willing (and knowledgeable) third party who will evaluate his coins for him.  For some small fee.  Mail them back to Jim and he can send the coins he chooses to PCGS.  At least this might weed out the bad coins he's missed and save him some money.
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 03:53:32 PM
If I got someone else to suss my coins out it would take ALL the fun and challenge out of it.
I have screwed up many a time but I do get the occasional win and doing that without the advantage of being able to view the coins in hand gives me more kudos I think :)
as far as PCGS submission go I have only had 3 bodybagged so far and the lowest grade has been AU50 out of 16 coins.
I don't consider that an absolute failure on my first 2 attempts.
I have been having more fun than a Fox in a Chook house picking coins to send to the "plastics factory".
Of course it costs a few bob to play and if I couldn't afford it I wouldn't do it.
Most of my mates would spend more money at the pub than I do on coins in a year and at the end of the year I end up with a bunch of coins (Good, Bad and plain ugly some of em) but I do end up with something instead of a hangover and a grumpy missus :)

I thou rely enjoy the challenge involved and wouldn't give it up for quids :dance2:

It works out to be about $30 a coin and if I make a stuff up I will have that slab on my desk to remind me to be more studious next time :)
So at the moment I am Loving the Challenge and Living the Dream :dance::dance2::dance:
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: markn on December 27, 2013, 04:03:08 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='38237' dateline='1388121812'If I got someone else to suss my coins out it would take ALL the fun and challenge out of it.
I have screwed up many a time but I do get the occasional win and doing that without the advantage of being able to view the coins in hand gives me more kudos I think :)
as far as PCGS submission go I have only had 3 bodybagged so far and the lowest grade has been AU50 out of 16 coins.
I don't consider that an absolute failure on my first 2 attempts.
I have been having more fun than a Fox in a Chook house picking coins to send to the "plastics factory".
Of course it costs a few bob to play and if I couldn't afford it I wouldn't do it.
Most of my mates would spend more money at the pub than I do on coins in a year and at the end of the year I end up with a bunch of coins (Good, Bad and plain ugly some of em) but I do end up with something instead of a hangover and a grumpy missus :)

I thou rely enjoy the challenge involved and wouldn't give it up for quids :dance2:

It works out to be about $30 a coin and if I make a stuff up I will have that slab on my desk to remind me to be more studious next time :)
So at the moment I am Loving the Challenge and Living the Dream :dance::dance2::dance:

Good on you Jim :) Don't want you to get discouraged!
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 04:17:00 PM
QuoteGood on you Jim Smile Don't want you to get discouraged!
Thanks Mate :drinks:
I think anything worth learning is best done through experience and the sheer joy of eventually mastering something through work sweat and tears is bloody awesome :wavemulticolor:

Something as simple as mastering the long wand without tuition is SOOOO satisfying , albeit somewhat painful when the flies get stuck in various parts of the body .
But when you land your very first trout on fly is a memory that you will never forget.

Getting good grades from TPG's is pretty much the same.
I know it will be costly, I know it will be painful and frustrating at times.
I also KNOW that at the end of the day I WILL master it and what a smug happy  bugger I'll be when I finally "Get it Right".
I have never given up on something I have wanted to do and just because I'm getting a bit long in the tooth that is NO excuse to start giving up now :)
Don't worry about me Mark I am defiantly not a "Quitter"
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: Fulvio on December 27, 2013, 04:21:02 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='38237' dateline='1388121812'If I got someone else to suss my coins out it would take ALL the fun and challenge out of it.

I get that. But its not exactly what I was suggesting.

Rather its more along the lines of having someone you trust keeping an eye out for specific items, and judging them 'in-hand' for suitability, rather than relying on shifty vendors with bad pics.

Look at it as an adjunct, not a replacement for what you currently do.

While not a formal arrangement, I have several people who seem to have volunteered to keep a lookout for me, and they occasionally offer me things I haven't been able to find for myself. I greatly appreciate their efforts, and I don't think I've knocked any offerings back yet. To me, this adds to, rather than detracts from, the fun.

YMMV. ;)
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: trout on December 27, 2013, 05:02:09 PM
I do get help occasionally , just a week or so ago I received a 2014 coin set hand picked for me by  Feathers :good:
Title: RE: Cleaned or die polishing Marks?
Post by: dcoin on December 27, 2013, 05:47:13 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='38237' dateline='1388121812'If I got someone else to suss my coins out it would take ALL the fun and challenge out of it.
I have screwed up many a time but I do get the occasional win and doing that without the advantage of being able to view the coins in hand gives me more kudos I think :)
as far as PCGS submission go I have only had 3 bodybagged so far and the lowest grade has been AU50 out of 16 coins.
I don't consider that an absolute failure on my first 2 attempts.
I have been having more fun than a Fox in a Chook house picking coins to send to the "plastics factory".
Of course it costs a few bob to play and if I couldn't afford it I wouldn't do it.
Most of my mates would spend more money at the pub than I do on coins in a year and at the end of the year I end up with a bunch of coins (Good, Bad and plain ugly some of em) but I do end up with something instead of a hangover and a grumpy missus :)

I thou rely enjoy the challenge involved and wouldn't give it up for quids :dance2:

It works out to be about $30 a coin and if I make a stuff up I will have that slab on my desk to remind me to be more studious next time :)
So at the moment I am Loving the Challenge and Living the Dream :dance::dance2::dance:

nothing teaches you faster than making your own mistake, I have made some poor grading and purchasing decisions in the past (luckily they were on cheaper coins) and I can guarantee that you learn from them and limit the chance of making that mistake again.

If you are still working out dealer/auction house grading and how it converts to PCGS what I would recommend is viewing auctions in the flesh and you can either purchase the coins or simply see what they go for and see how that matches up with your opinion.

I have sent 100's of coins into PCGS, at the end of the day as long as i'm happy with my collection that's all that matters. The grades are nice for re-selling purposes and forming sets, however, the main thing is you are happy with the coin.

Quote from: 'trout' pid='38250' dateline='1388125929'I do get help occasionally , just a week or so ago I received a 2014 coin set hand picked for me by  Feathers :good:

There is nothing wrong with getting a second opinion. I have someone that I always use to get a second opinion on what I consider to be expensive coins (I note every ones definition of expensive will be different). It can never hurt to have a second set of eyes, whether it's a friend, this forum, a dealer, pcgs, etc.