Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: gac_1808 on December 06, 2013, 09:08:22 PM

Title: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: gac_1808 on December 06, 2013, 09:08:22 PM
With the 2005 $1- Gallipoli Mobile Press "S" $1 mintmark, is there anyway to tell the difference between the coins issued at the 2 shows that the RAM had the mobile press at - the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo held in Sydney from April 2005 and the Sydney ANDA Coin Show in August 2005?
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: trout on December 06, 2013, 10:28:26 PM
Quote from: 'gac_1808' pid='36408' dateline='1386326302'With the 2005 $1- Gallipoli Mobile Press "S" $1 mintmark, is there anyway to tell the difference between the coins issued at the 2 shows that the RAM had the mobile press at - the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo held in Sydney from April 2005 and the Sydney ANDA Coin Show in August 2005?

You will need to talk to Goldie about that.
To me they are the same :ok:
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 06, 2013, 10:42:47 PM
Quote from: 'gac_1808' pid='36408' dateline='1386326302'With the 2005 $1- Gallipoli Mobile Press "S" $1 mintmark, is there anyway to tell the difference between the coins issued at the 2 shows that the RAM had the mobile press at - the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo held in Sydney from April 2005 and the Sydney ANDA Coin Show in August 2005?

Yes there is, it is only small but,
with the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo coins, if you look at the reverse there is a mark on the rim at about 4 o'clock.
It is only a small mark, if you know where to look it's easy to pick up.
I know this sounds a bit silly but it appears on all the   Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo coins but not on the ANDA coins.
Stranger than fiction. To see is to believe.
Over the weekend I will dig out one of each & scan to show you.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: runway on December 06, 2013, 10:58:25 PM
Quote from: 'interest' pid='36418' dateline='1386331967'
Quote from: 'gac_1808' pid='36408' dateline='1386326302'With the 2005 $1- Gallipoli Mobile Press "S" $1 mintmark, is there anyway to tell the difference between the coins issued at the 2 shows that the RAM had the mobile press at - the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo held in Sydney from April 2005 and the Sydney ANDA Coin Show in August 2005?

Yes there is, it is only small but,
with the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo coins, if you look at the reverse there is a mark on the rim at about 4 o'clock.
It is only a small mark, if you know where to look it's easy to pick up.
I know this sounds a bit silly but it appears on all the   Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo coins but not on the ANDA coins.
Stranger than fiction. To see is to believe.
Over the weekend I will dig out one of each & scan to show you.
That would be great Interest,I attended the 2005 ANDA Show and got the portable press $1 at the time,didn't realise the Pacific had mobile press there...the excitement at the time was the 2005 World Heritage Site PNC with the COA 50c
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: Goldseeker on December 07, 2013, 12:20:00 PM
Interesting reading.   I was not aware that the Portable Press had been attending the Pacific Stamp Explorer Stamp Expo.

If by chance, did the Pacific Expo Counter Stamp come in a specially overprinted/stamped folder.   If so, any chance of a scan of both sides of the folder with coin inserted please?

The only other way that I can think of identifying the actual place of minting is by the location of the reading on the side of the coin in relation to the "A" of Australia.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 07, 2013, 08:29:36 PM
OOOPS,, the mark is not on the reverse, it's on the obverse that was my mistake it's been a few years since I looked at theses.
The mark does not scan so well but I did notice the difference between the two "S" 's
the top one is from the stamp expo the bottom one is from the ANDA show.
The folders are the same, the barcodes match
(http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb22/interest88/gal-stamp_zps11907cf7.gif)
(http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb22/interest88/gal-anda_zpsb4cbd5b3.gif)
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: trout on December 07, 2013, 08:48:06 PM
Looks like the Stamp expo coin's counter stamp is "wonky" and a bit of doubling there.
Not enough of a difference to make me want to rush out and acquire one but there is a difference :ok:
I wonder if the operator at the stamp expo still has his job :angel:
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 07, 2013, 08:57:21 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='36493' dateline='1386411486'Looks like the Stamp expo coin's counter stamp is "wonky" and a bit of doubling there.
Not enough of a difference to make me want to rush out and acquire one but there is a difference :ok:
I wonder if the operator at the stamp expo still has his job :angel:

Same guy!!
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: trout on December 07, 2013, 09:05:27 PM
QuoteSame guy!!

He must have been either ON or OFF his meds on the stamp day :laugh2:
Dunno about the Mint but if anyone did shoddy work like that for me he would be "Unemployed" in a heartbeat :ok:
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: runway on December 08, 2013, 12:06:41 AM
I take offence to the certain above comments about the decent Guy who was operating the mobile press at the time.
Decent bloke just doing his job
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: Fulvio on December 08, 2013, 02:23:00 AM
Quote from: 'interest' pid='36492' dateline='1386410376'I did notice the difference between the two "S" 's

Its not a reliable indicator of anything. I've got batches of MYO's produced at the same time where some coins show this doubling and others don't.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: gac_1808 on December 09, 2013, 07:38:00 PM
Many Thanks for the information and pictures/scans.

Greatly appreciated
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 09, 2013, 07:39:16 PM
Quote from: 'gac_1808' pid='36653' dateline='1386580080'Many Thanks for the information and pictures/scans.

Greatly appreciated

More to come. In a little while.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: gac_1808 on December 09, 2013, 07:40:15 PM
Looking forward to the additional information.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 16, 2013, 11:13:19 PM
[align=center]Thank you Markn for the images.[/align]

Going back to the 2005, I'm hoping that this convince you of the difference between the Sydney Stamp Expo & the ANDA mobile press coins.
This difference was caused in-situ at Sydney Stamp Expo.

First image is of the Sydney Stamp Expo coin.
Please note the mark on the rim between the "I&A"
of AUSTRALIA

(http://www.australian-coins.net/images/interest/pacific-stamp-o.jpg)
The second image is from the ANDA show.
There is no mark on the ANDA coin.
(http://www.australian-coins.net/images/interest/anda-o.jpg)
The third image is from Sydney Stamp Expo
This is the "S" MM from the Sydney Stamp Expo coin.
Note the bottom of the MM.
(http://www.australian-coins.net/images/interest/pacific-mm.jpg)
the foruth image is from ANDA
This is the "S" MM from ANDA.
(http://www.australian-coins.net/images/interest/anda-mm.jpg)
As you can see the MINT MARK has been cleaned up, pressure has been corrected & perhaps there was something that caused this mark where the coin was placed into Mobile press prior to stamping,
that has also been corrected for the ANDA show..

This is not just my theory, it was bought up back in 2005 in one of the other forums.
Brissyboy & others who participated in that forum would be able to verify as all their coins purchased over varying times of  the weekend, of the Sydney Stamp Expo all had the same particular mark in the same spot.

If you check your coins this should let you know where they came from.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: Fulvio on December 17, 2013, 12:16:54 AM
So if I'm reading this right, we're talking about a die variety rather than a doubling error?
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: purplepennyhunter on December 17, 2013, 07:36:41 AM
I have looked at mine and my spares. They are all show coins but I don't know which came from which show.

1. 1 x shallow mintmark no rim mark
2. 1 x shallow mintmark with doubling and no rim mark
3. 1 x shallow mintmark and rim mark

So I can (can I) reasonably deduce:
1. ANDA show
2. ANDA show
3. Pacific Expo
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: Goldseeker on December 17, 2013, 09:44:45 AM
Thanks one and all.   I have just spent the last couple of hours correcting my records for these coins.

Now I should be up to date.

Great photos by the way.
Title: RE: 2005 Gallipoli $1- Mobile Press Coins
Post by: interest on December 17, 2013, 01:42:57 PM
Quote from: 'purplepennyhunter' pid='37318' dateline='1387228001'I have looked at mine and my spares. They are all show coins but I don't know which came from which show.

1. 1 x shallow mintmark no rim mark
2. 1 x shallow mintmark with doubling and no rim mark
3. 1 x shallow mintmark and rim mark

So I can (can I) reasonably deduce:
1. ANDA show
2. ANDA show
3. Pacific Expo

Yes that is exactly what I would decduce