I noodled the below scanned coin several weeks ago and what made it stand out was the colour. It is supposed to be a 1994 Kangaroo $1 coin but it is distinctly Pink in colour. It resembles copper tone.
I took it into a well known Coin Dealer in Melbourne this today because he had a metal tester that determines or assays metals. OK, it is a small desk job but I still think a reliable machine as this coin dealer is not the only one I have seen with it.
The results from his machine are very interesting;
Copper 96.77; Genuine coin 97.81;
Nickel 2.2; Genuine coin 2.09;
Steel 0.0913; Genuine coin 0.015 Gold (True).
My weight 8.7 grams; Genuine coin 9 grams;
My Diameter 24.6 mm; Genuine coin 25 mm;
The coin is slightly thinner that the normal coin.
Colour Distinctly Pink; Genuine coin Pale yellow.
The dealer has stated that going on what I have seen and what I have measured, this is a wrong planchet.
Can anyone else throw some light on this coin please.
Another forum member visited the same dealer after me and he and the dealer spoke about my coin after I had left the shop. I knew nothing of this conversation till I met up with the forum member later.
Here are the scans of this coin:
Hmmm... my immediate reaction if I'd found it would be its had a swim in some acid. Which doesn't rule out an off-metal strike, but it does explain the weight loss. The bit that stands out is the steel.. there shouldn't be any, should there?
could it be an attempted forgery??
I'm not sure anything can be determined from a coin that badly damaged. The pink colour and weight/size loss can all be explained by going swimming in acid or something else corrosive, but acid wouldn't cause severe "roadkill" damage by itself.
I certainly wouldn't put "wrong planchet" high up on the list of probable causes. I'd put "combination acid and roadkill damage" and "counterfeit" both higher. A counterfeiter might put their coins through a rock tumbler to simulate wear and try to disguise the poor die-work.
A genuine $1 coin shouldn't test out at 98% copper. The target is 92% copper, 6% aluminium, 2% nickel.
Given that aluminium is a lot higher up on the galvanic series than copper prolonged exposure to sea water (or a weak acid) could easily result in a "skin" that is almost pure copper. XRF has almost no surface penetration so it doesn't surprise me much that it's testing as 98% copper.
Interesting ...