Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: MattGold on October 30, 2013, 09:30:56 PM

Title: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: MattGold on October 30, 2013, 09:30:56 PM
Hey all, I'm a little interested in these coins but something is throwing me off about how they are clipped. I can't quite put my finger on it. Any help would be appreciated. Cheers

(http://i44.tinypic.com/28qu5jo.jpg)
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: Fulvio on October 30, 2013, 09:42:50 PM
They look wrong.. no Blakesley effect for starters.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: trout on October 30, 2013, 09:47:50 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='32914' dateline='1383131570'They look wrong.. no Blakesley effect for starters.

:agreed:
looks as dodgy as a $3 note :dodgy:
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: runway on October 30, 2013, 11:34:40 PM
Oh dear MattGold where did you get these from?
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: Fulvio on October 31, 2013, 01:38:59 AM
While the 5¢ looks like it was cut with tin snips, something else was bothering me about the 10¢...

(http://fulvio.jovianprojects.com.au/coins/forum/DodgyClip.jpg)
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: purplepennyhunter on October 31, 2013, 07:22:09 AM
I'd like to see the clip site under the microscope to see if there's fishtailing. I think I can see flattening of the rim at the edges of the 10c clip indicating it's real, maybe slight blakesley there too. What's on the obverse at 6 o'clock protruding at the rim on the 5c? I think more investigation is needed, these look real and quite exciting.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: MattGold on October 31, 2013, 07:26:37 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='32921' dateline='1383145739'While the 5¢ looks like it was cut with tin snips, something else was bothering me about the 10¢...

(http://fulvio.jovianprojects.com.au/coins/forum/DodgyClip.jpg)

I'm a tad slow and haven't picked up what else is bothering you about it?? lol... Is that the same coin that you posted but just edited?

Runaway- On a facebook selling site, the bids up to $310 at the moment, it is these 2 coins plus 2 blank 5c pieces in the same condition.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: markn on October 31, 2013, 07:29:45 AM
I think the 10c is real.  You can see some blakesley effect on it.  I also see tapering of the rim next to the missing region of the coin.

The 5c?  Well the jury is out on that one.  It could be real.  I've seen US clips that look like that because they fall apart AFTER they were struck.  As to it being cut with tin snips?  I think anyone would struggle cutting something that small with that small a radius that looks so neat with tin snips.  If it was cut with something it wasn't tin snips.  I'd like to see the edge.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: MattGold on October 31, 2013, 07:30:39 AM
Quote from: 'purplepennyhunter' pid='32930' dateline='1383166329'I'd like to see the clip site under the microscope to see if there's fishtailing. I think I can see flattening of the rim at the edges of the 10c clip indicating it's real, maybe slight blakesley there too. What's on the obverse at 6 o'clock protruding at the rim on the 5c? I think more investigation is needed, these look real and quite exciting.

I just got the obverse image just now, the 10c may be real but still unsure about the 5c.
(http://i39.tinypic.com/iw2mac.jpg)
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: markn on October 31, 2013, 07:31:42 AM
Quote from: 'MattGold' pid='32932' dateline='1383166597'Runaway- On a facebook selling site, the bids up to $310 at the moment, it is these 2 coins plus 2 blank 5c pieces in the same condition.

Even if they are real that's massively over-priced.  Don't buy them.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: MattGold on October 31, 2013, 07:32:20 AM
I will see if I can get some photos of the edge for you.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: markn on October 31, 2013, 07:33:05 AM
Quote from: 'MattGold' pid='32934' dateline='1383166839'I just got the obverse image just now, the 10c may be real but still unsure about the 5c.
(http://i39.tinypic.com/iw2mac.jpg)

They are both real.  But at $310?  Pass.  I'd value the 10c at $30, the 5c at perhaps $75 because it's so big.  The 5c blanks?  $30 each.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: ausjack on October 31, 2013, 07:41:02 AM
I would really like to know how these type of coins make it out of the mint..not that I'm complaining that they do as it's actually GREAT that they do so I'll keep lookin :)
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: markn on October 31, 2013, 07:43:15 AM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='32940' dateline='1383167462'I would really like to know how these type of coins make it out of the mint..not that I'm complaining that they do as it's actually GREAT that they do so I'll keep lookin :)

That's a good question AJ.  I wish I knew too.  The 5c should have fallen through a sorting grid (assuming they used one) that drops out all the small stuff and bits of metal before the coins were struck.  The 10c could have made it out because it's not that much different to a normal 10c.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: Fulvio on October 31, 2013, 10:25:44 AM
What was bothering me was the shape of the bite. It looked like a different diameter. But if everyone else reckons they're real, who am I to argue? ;)
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: markn on October 31, 2013, 11:06:32 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='32959' dateline='1383177344'What was bothering me was the shape of the bite. It looked like a different diameter. But if everyone else reckons they're real, who am I to argue? ;)

Remember that the clip you see after the coin is struck isn't the same size as it was when it was actually cut.  When the coin is struck the metal will flow toward the missing area of the coin.  And it won't flow equally.  The path of least resistance suggests that the metal near the rims will move less than the metal in the middle of the clipped area.  This would usually result in a clip appearing "shallower" than the original diameter.  Pretty much exactly what you see in the comparison image you posted above.

You'd also expect more metal flow into the empty area where the striking pressure is higher.  That is areas of highest relief in the design.  You can see exactly this on the 5c.  Note on the obverse image near the top of the queens portrait that the clip appears to step inwards right where the top queens head intersects the edge of the clip.  The fields are deformed less meaning less flow into the missing area while the queens head is deformed more so you get more metal flowing into the missing area.
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: Fulvio on October 31, 2013, 11:18:24 AM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='32974' dateline='1383179792'And it won't flow equally.

Yep. I plead lack of sleep in my defence for forgetting that.

Awesome explanation btw. :ok:
Title: RE: Just doesn't look right to me.
Post by: MattGold on November 07, 2013, 01:55:24 PM
They ended up selling for $380.