Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: Australian coin on October 30, 2013, 11:06:38 AM

Title: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Australian coin on October 30, 2013, 11:06:38 AM
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/TS08-1951-AUSTRALIAN-ERROR-MISSTRIKE-HALF-PENNY-HIT-WITH-THE-SHILLING-DIE-RARE-/321238256048?pt=AU_Coins2&hash=item4acb4ac9b0#ht_63wt_1161

yeah would have been a nice error, but I think someone smashed a shilling into it....
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Robster on October 30, 2013, 11:18:19 AM
Always amazed by people 'creativity'.  lol.:shok:
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Unicorn on October 30, 2013, 12:45:27 PM
Oh dear ....... has anyone had the heart to break the news to them yet?
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on October 30, 2013, 01:43:14 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='32854' dateline='1383099327'Oh dear ....... has anyone had the heart to break the news to them yet?

I just told him:

Sorry to say, this really nice error has been ruined by being crushed in a vise against a shilling. Apart from the impossibility of being restruck as a shilling, even is such a thing were possible, it would look completely different. The only way to get incused lettering is from another coin, not a die. Pity, this shed job has destroyed any value it previously had. :(
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Sapyx on October 30, 2013, 05:47:24 PM
I'm not sure there ever was an 'error' here, unless you guys are seeing something I'm not. All I can see is damage caused by compressing a shilling into a penny.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Unicorn on October 30, 2013, 05:55:45 PM
Nah Sap, I think AC was just saying it would have been a nice error if it had really been struck with a shilling die ... (emphasis on really).
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on October 30, 2013, 06:22:57 PM
It was a broadstrike before it was wrecked. Compare it to this:

(http://www.australian-threepence.com/images/australia-1947-1d-broadstrike.jpg)
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Unicorn on October 30, 2013, 06:34:58 PM
Do ya reckon .... I thought that was just from the squishing it got. Must have another look see.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on October 30, 2013, 07:14:54 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='32893' dateline='1383120298'I thought that was just from the squishing it got.

Nup. The squishing is clearly obvious on the obverse, and you can see the edge of the shilling clearly as well.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Unicorn on October 31, 2013, 12:15:15 PM
I've had another look and I can see the denticles on the halfpenny all the way around the edgle on both the obverse and reverse ...... do ya still reckon it was a broadstrike?

Seller still has it up there.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: nealeffendi on November 01, 2013, 09:49:46 AM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='32893' dateline='1383120298'Do ya reckon .... I thought that was just from the squishing it got. Must have another look see.

I agree, I think the rim is just an ordinary rim distorted by the shed work.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: emu666 on November 01, 2013, 09:58:26 AM
Definitely not an error at any stage.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on November 01, 2013, 11:56:02 AM
Quote from: 'emu666' pid='33109' dateline='1383262106'Definitely not an error at any stage.

As usual with these disagreements, the answer is to replicate it.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: emu666 on November 01, 2013, 12:20:31 PM
What can you not understand about the evidence that has pointed out to you?
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: ausjack on November 01, 2013, 12:30:04 PM
GEEBUS emu don't get him started mate or we'll never hear the end of it :winkextra:
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on November 01, 2013, 12:30:55 PM
What evidence? All I see is conjecture.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: emu666 on November 01, 2013, 12:58:48 PM
look at the coin itself.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: ausjack on November 01, 2013, 01:22:35 PM
I'm warnin ya emu, ya gonna get him goin :mocking:
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: trout on November 01, 2013, 01:44:32 PM
If I had a decent press I could make some of these in a heartbeat.
All that would be needed is a ha penny a shilling and plenty of cloth to pad the obverse of the ha penny to stop the steel on the press obliterating the design.
The S and H are incused and the original denticals of the ha penny are all on the outer edge of the ha penny.
Defiantly PMD and most unlikely to have been a  broadstrike before the damage was done.
This is just my opinion of this coin :ok:
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Unicorn on November 01, 2013, 01:50:04 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='32986' dateline='1383183915'I've had another look and I can see the denticles on the halfpenny all the way around the edgle on both the obverse and reverse

That was why I reckoned it wasn't a broadstrike ..... I might be wrong.
Title: RE: hmm, i dont know, was a good coin
Post by: Fulvio on November 01, 2013, 02:28:38 PM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='33164' dateline='1383274355'I'm warnin ya emu, ya gonna get him goin

Nup. At the end of the day, its a ruined coin, which everyone agrees. So arguing about what it used to be is kinda pointless really.

EIther way, its a terrible thing to do to any coin. :(