Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: Ozcoins on October 22, 2013, 12:52:51 PM

Title: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Ozcoins on October 22, 2013, 12:52:51 PM
I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: markn on October 22, 2013, 01:03:52 PM
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31811' dateline='1382408571'I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.

Depends entirely on the grade.  A common from circulation mule might get $400-$500 raw on eBay almost regardless of the condition.  If you got it graded up and it came back an AU53 or better you will most likely get more for it.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Goldseeker on October 22, 2013, 01:18:24 PM
I have been tossing with the idea to have all my remaining mules slabbed but a couples of things are against this idea.   These are:

1.   Cost; and
2.   A place to store the slabbed coins.

As a result I am still tossing up with the idea.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: stevo1962 on October 22, 2013, 01:36:30 PM
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31811' dateline='1382408571'I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.

Post some photos so we can estimate the grade.I have intensions of slabbing my mules that are EF or better and the value would certainly
be enhanced at that level
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Fulvio on October 22, 2013, 01:49:07 PM
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='31820' dateline='1382410104'1.   Cost; and
2.   A place to store the slabbed coins.

Which are pretty big negatives. Not only to the slabbing, but to buying slabs.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: lacey on October 22, 2013, 02:03:20 PM
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='31820' dateline='1382410104'I have been tossing with the idea to have all my remaining mules slabbed but a couples of things are against this idea.   These are:

1.   Cost; and
2.   A place to store the slabbed coins.

As a result I am still tossing up with the idea.

give them to me.  I don't have any and it will solve your problem.  I promise I will give them a lovely new home I will look after them 4 ever
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Ozcoins on October 22, 2013, 02:05:28 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='31827' dateline='1382411190'
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31811' dateline='1382408571'I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.

Post some photos so we can estimate the grade.I have intensions of slabbing my mules that are EF or better and the value would certainly
be enhanced at that level

There is a photo under 'my lucky day' topic.
After looking at it, the photo is probably not good enough to work out the grade.
I might try to get a better photo to post here later.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: markn on October 22, 2013, 02:06:19 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='31834' dateline='1382411947'
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='31820' dateline='1382410104'1.   Cost; and
2.   A place to store the slabbed coins.

Which are pretty big negatives. Not only to the slabbing, but to buying slabs.

I see having a coin slabbed as having a two fold purpose.  The first is to protect the coin better.  The second is to enhance any potential resale value.  If protection is your primary motive then the extra space taken up could be a careful consideration.  Because getting a lot of low value coins is not only expensive it can also take up a whole lot of space.

But if enhancing future resale is your primary motive?  Well you can easily get the BEST coins in your collection slabbed (which might only be 20-40 coins) and have the extra space EASILY paid for by the value adding you perform.  Let's take the mule as an example.  Given that the real value difference between a raw AU55 mule ($450-500) and a slabbed AU55 mule ($800-$1100) is so large the cost of the extra space is FAR out-weighed by the extra value.  

In Goldy's case he has 30 odd mules, surely the extra value he'd add to them getting them graded would pay for a bigger SDB MANY times over.  You don't have to put them in slab boxes, you can lay them flat, stack them, put rubber bands around them.  Do whatever you like to make them fit.  And if Goldy has all of his mules in a press in album there's a lot of dead space that's using up already.

I guess it all comes down to your priorities.  To me finding the right coin and buying it is just one step.  The next step is storing them properly and the final step is the  preparation for their (inevitable) disposal.  To me, many collectors put a huge amount of effort into the first step, put little thought into the second, and none at all into the final one.  Yet all three are an integral part of owning a coin.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: stevo1962 on October 22, 2013, 02:23:32 PM
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31837' dateline='1382412928'
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='31827' dateline='1382411190'
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31811' dateline='1382408571'I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.

Post some photos so we can estimate the grade.I have intensions of slabbing my mules that are EF or better and the value would certainly
be enhanced at that level

There is a photo under 'my lucky day' topic.
After looking at it, the photo is probably not good enough to work out the grade.
I might try to get a better photo to post here later.

 Looks to be probably VF  or VF+ from the photos so might make AU50 which to me would be on the cusp of slabbing potential
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Fulvio on October 22, 2013, 02:27:04 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='31838' dateline='1382412979'The first is to protect the coin better.  The second is to enhance any potential resale value.

Leaving aside the second, which has been argued to death and is probably moot for collectors anyway, that leaves protection.

What does a slab offer? Mechanical rigidity and environmental protection.

Rigidity is pretty pointless for lumps of metal. Even impact resistance is of low value since there's not a lot of rough handling by most collectors.

So it comes down to excluding air and the contaminants it carries. And given that any sealed inert container does that job equally well, I fail to see the advantage of a big block of plastic over a polyethylene or polypropylene bag, flip or page.

But there's a third aspect to this. Bragging rights. Likely closely related to value, of course. Clearly there are some who love collecting packaging, and this is probably a high priority for them.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: stevo1962 on October 22, 2013, 02:41:37 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='31843' dateline='1382414224'
Quote from: 'markn' pid='31838' dateline='1382412979'The first is to protect the coin better.  The second is to enhance any potential resale value.

Leaving aside the second, which has been argued to death and is probably moot for collectors anyway, that leaves protection.

The only reason that I would slab a coin is to enhance the value.If you collect coins for the sake of collecting then slabbing will just increase your costs.Although if you decide to slab these coins and leave them to your heirs then they would enjoy the added value .Differnet strokes for different folks that's all it is
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: markn on October 22, 2013, 02:47:36 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='31843' dateline='1382414224'Rigidity is pretty pointless for lumps of metal. Even impact resistance is of low value since there's not a lot of rough handling by most collectors.

Wrong.  People drop coins all the time.  Drop things on coins.  Drop things on coins in holders.  Scratch coins in holders.  Drop coins in holders out of album pages, boxes or whatever.

There are other holders that give some impact protection too but standard sized slabs (PCGS NGC) have some advantages over these because they ARE easier to store.  Either in the custom boxes or stacking them.  Capsules, for example, look great but are an absolute pain to store sensibly.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: emu666 on October 22, 2013, 04:27:10 PM
Quote from: 'Ozcoins' pid='31811' dateline='1382408571'I am trying to decide if I should slab the 'mule' I found.
I am interested in people's ideas on this.


Have you had your other coins independently graded?
If so, then you probably should.

If you haven't, then there is no point in it.

I still have the first mule I found. It is in a 2 x 2 and labelled "1. 7/5/04".
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: markn on October 22, 2013, 04:28:59 PM
Quote from: 'emu666' pid='31853' dateline='1382421430'If you haven't, then there is no point in it.

Why?  A mule you find for $1 is (in my opinion) a great coin to be your first in a slab.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Cooper S on October 22, 2013, 05:04:15 PM
can you post pics?
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: robbiegal on October 22, 2013, 07:28:35 PM
pics already posted the other day in another thread

'my lucky day thread' post 13
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: trout on October 22, 2013, 09:19:09 PM
YES do it Mate :good:
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Ozcoins on October 22, 2013, 09:57:48 PM
Now that a few people have responded, here are the things I have been weighing up (not in any particular order).
1. Cost
Someone has very generously said they will include my coin with their next submission to PCGS.  The cost was going to be something like $35 or $40 - not exactly "cheap", but not all that much compared to the value of the coin.
2. Risk
There is some small amount of risk that something will go wrong and the coin will be damaged/lost in transit although this seems pretty unlikely.
3. Resale value
I am not planning on selling, but it is almost inevitable that it will happen at some point - even if not done by me.  If I were to die tomorrow, it would go to someone else who would most likely get better "value" out of selling it than they would in keeping it.  My coin collection is also in reality something that could be sold in dire straights.  As pointed out a mule on ebay seems to go for $400-$500 at the lower end.  It also seems some better coins can go for lower values than they would if they were PCGS graded.  Someone recently posted about being an ebay loser, not getting what they were hoping for.  It seems that the values of the graded coins seem more stable - ie fairly well connected to the grade.  I agree that there is not much point paying for slabbing of a low end coin, as the low end prices seem to be fairly stable as well.
I think the coin I found is above average for a circulated year 2000 $1 coin, but I have no real idea what grade it would end up with.  Anyone in Sydney have a selection of slabbed mules in different grades that I could compare mine to??  (I am not really expecting a "yes" to that) More seriously, is there someone in Sydney who could take a look and give me an idea of what it would grade at?
4. Storage/Protection
I only own 1 slabbed coin (a nice 1972 5c). It is nice, but does strike me as a little "sterile".  I think it was someone here who described slabs as "coffins" and I can almost see why.
5. US company?
It irks me a bit that we would be relying on an overseas company to do this.  Is the best we can do in Australia dodgy grading companies?  Surely we can do better....
6. Accurate/trustworthy grade.  
I think this is closely related to ebay sale prices.  
If someone listed an EF Mule for sale on ebay, what are the chances that it actually is that grade?  
If someone said I have a PCGS graded Mule MS58, I think you could be fairly confident of what you will receive.

At this point I am leaning towards slabbing, but still not quite decided.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: robbiegal on October 22, 2013, 10:05:00 PM
hum
not sounding like PCGS is the best way for you to go with this little rarity
perhaps a clean off with something inert substance
a nice crisp saflip , a heat seal and viola - a well stored coin for the collection
I put my more fancy error coins in eagle mounts and like them that way, as I can remove them from the mount if I want to take photos and so on
I have an album that I keep them in and always enjoy that errors album
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: drakesterling on October 23, 2013, 01:01:08 AM
I am going to talk my own book here and say that, financially (and provided the coin won't body-bag), get the coin graded. All but uncirculated mules cost $65 to send to PCGS (insurance extra), and it's worth the cost if you turn a $400 ebay coin into an $800 ebay coin. pm me if you'd like more details on grading, as I do provide this service.

Eric
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: keldaw on October 23, 2013, 07:13:57 AM
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='31923' dateline='1382452268'I am going to talk my own book here and say that, financially (and provided the coin won't body-bag), get the coin graded. All but uncirculated mules cost $65 to send to PCGS (insurance extra), and it's worth the cost if you turn a $400 ebay coin into an $800 ebay coin. pm me if you'd like more details on grading, as I do provide this service.

Eric

hi eric , just a quick question because I know nothing about slab coins , but , you say it cost about $65 to send to PCGS to get slabbed and you have some listed for sale for $ 25.00 / $ 35.00 . ? am I reading this wrong , or just not following it the right way ?..  ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: Nevol on October 23, 2013, 07:37:09 AM
QuoteAll but uncirculated mules cost $65 to send to PCGS
Eric's was talking specifically about Mules. :angel:
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: purplepennyhunter on October 23, 2013, 08:20:58 AM
Different service levels vary in cost. Bulk is the cheapest, then moderns 1965+, economy, regular (mules fit here) then express the most expensive.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: emu666 on October 23, 2013, 08:29:23 AM
Quote from: 'keldaw' pid='31925' dateline='1382474637'
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='31923' dateline='1382452268'I am going to talk my own book here and say that, financially (and provided the coin won't body-bag), get the coin graded. All but uncirculated mules cost $65 to send to PCGS (insurance extra), and it's worth the cost if you turn a $400 ebay coin into an $800 ebay coin. pm me if you'd like more details on grading, as I do provide this service.

Eric

hi eric , just a quick question because I know nothing about slab coins , but , you say it cost about $65 to send to PCGS to get slabbed and you have some listed for sale for $ 25.00 / $ 35.00 . ? am I reading this wrong , or just not following it the right way ?..  ,, kel ,,


You could say that some coins, in some grades, are worth less than the slabbing cost.

But it would be more accurate to say that most coins in most grades are worth less than the slabbing cost.
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: drakesterling on October 23, 2013, 08:41:16 AM
Quote from: 'keldaw' pid='31925' dateline='1382474637'
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='31923' dateline='1382452268'I am going to talk my own book here and say that, financially (and provided the coin won't body-bag), get the coin graded. All but uncirculated mules cost $65 to send to PCGS (insurance extra), and it's worth the cost if you turn a $400 ebay coin into an $800 ebay coin. pm me if you'd like more details on grading, as I do provide this service.

Eric

hi eric , just a quick question because I know nothing about slab coins , but , you say it cost about $65 to send to PCGS to get slabbed and you have some listed for sale for $ 25.00 / $ 35.00 . ? am I reading this wrong , or just not following it the right way ?..  ,, kel ,,

Mules cost $65 to send. Decimals cost $30 to grade. The decimals you see on my website for $25+ are loss leaders.

Eric
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: trout on October 23, 2013, 08:57:33 AM
If you sent your Mule off to PCGS by itself then here is a breakdown of the costs.

Postage from Aus to PCGS =$22
Economy grading  cost      =$25
Variety attribution cost    =$24
Return postage from PCGS =$54 45

Total costs for the submission will be $125.45

This is a great example to show that a bulk submission  is more economical than just sending 1 coin at a time.

The $65 service offered by drakesterling is quite attractive compared to sending this off by yourself :ok:
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: robbiegal on October 23, 2013, 09:03:53 AM
does that include the $8 processing fee as well?
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: trout on October 23, 2013, 09:05:49 AM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='31942' dateline='1382481233'does that include the $8 processing fee as well?

:dash1:
Nope I forgot all about that one :blush:
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: purplepennyhunter on October 23, 2013, 10:01:18 AM
No variety attribution as the mule has it's own number. Remember Trout you had to join (https://www.pcgs.com/store/memberships.aspx) as well.

We like to send coins in multiple of 20 to make the most of that return postage charge.
see this link right at the bottom (http://www.pcgs.com/servicesandfees/)
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: trout on October 23, 2013, 10:22:48 AM
Quote from: 'purplepennyhunter' pid='31954' dateline='1382484678'No variety attribution as the mule has it's own number. Remember Trout you had to join (https://www.pcgs.com/store/memberships.aspx) as well.

We like to send coins in multiple of 20 to make the most of that return postage charge.
see this link right at the bottom (http://www.pcgs.com/servicesandfees/)

Yes I did But the 4 free submissions (regular) at $45 a pop covered that fee nicely :yahoo:
It did cost ma another $80 in postage and that makes it $20 per coin :dash1:

I sent 12 coins in with my first submission at a cost of about $400 which works out at about $33 a coin.
So sending batches of 20 at a time would be FAR more economical :good:
Title: RE: Should I slab my 'dollar mule'?
Post by: keldaw on October 23, 2013, 06:08:21 PM
thank you all for the answers , I think that cuts me out , as I don't

  have enough coins in the condition to warrant that cost.

 thanks the same , now I have an idea ..      ,, kel ,,