http://www.change.org/en-AU/petitions/the-liberal-party-of-australia-reconsider-your-plan-for-a-fttn-nbn-in-favour-of-a-superior-ftth-nbn
Regardless of who voted for what, we now have a government that is determined to undo everything their predecessors put in place. That seems to be Aussie politics nowadays.
But the NBN should not be a political football. This is critical infrastructure that we desperately need if we're going to have any hope of competing in a wired world. And they want to wreck it, implementing a substandard money-saver to balance their books.
This is one petition the whole country should sign.
I am sure Malcolm Turnbull knows better but he is a good party man and toeing the line. What a shame -we all lose out for the sake of political point scoring!
Why should we the voters, be paying $43BILLION on something that only a few will use.
Put the money to something that will ASSIST one and all.
Totally agree Fulvio. Labor's NBN is a brilliant infrastructure project that will benefit all Australian's in a modern digital economy. I've signed the petition and hope the current government recognise that FTTH is far superior.
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='27866' dateline='1378890055'Why should we the voters, be paying $43BILLION on something that only a few will use.
Put the money to something that will ASSIST one and all.
:agreed:
I live in the sticks and will NEVER get access .
I am sooo sick of coughing up for extra dollars for the mob that live in the big smoke that get ALL the benefits without producing much :dash1:
43 Billion would do wonders to us mob that live in the bush and produce at least 80% of Australia's wealth :ok:
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='27866' dateline='1378890055'Why should we the voters, be paying $43BILLION on something that only a few will use.
Because if we don't, everybody will suffer, whether they live in the city or the bush. Face it, its a digital world now, and we can no more stick to Merinos and Wheat than buggy whip manufacturers could ignore those new fangled horseless carriages.
Without a decent infrastructure, we're screwed. Do you realise Botswana completed its own implementation of our NBN back in 2008? How well do you think we'll compete when all of Africa becomes as tech saturated as Asia already is?
One would have thought having your economy creamed by China and India would have taught people a valuable lesson, but perhaps not, eh?
This has nothing to do with faster access to Facebook either. Have a look at the volumes of data produced by even middling installations. Say a radio telescope or the synchrotron out at Clayton for example. You think that's going to be transported by carrier pigeon? :angel:
QuoteYou think that's going to be transported by carrier pigeon?
My wireless connection is not much faster than a carrier pigeon at the moment :ok:
If you Mob in the cities want this then why not dig into your own pockets and pay for it yourself, What is wrong with "User pays"
Billions of dollars is better spent elsewhere than "Faster Porn downloads" imho :ireful:
I live in a city
I have broadband
and I have paid for it over the past 10 years
we were some of the first in OZ to get it
everybody whinged about it
it was voluntary sign on
it's fantastic
and I love it too
big deal about getting data faster... your brain wont compute / digest this info as quick.
are our young ones smarter than us cause they grew up with this technology
many other areas to be more beneficial to all
:angel::taunt:
I see it as vital for health in the future
more and more health services are being delivered through video link
computer link
so with broadband and medical broadband
someone like trout could cut his toe off in outta WA
and a surgeon in America could watch and tell the local doc the step by step to sew it back on
my daughter works for a company that manufacturers the robots that do surgery and/or do all the instruments for the surgeon during the surgery
so the surgeon can be in America and the surgery could take place in outta WA
but the speed has be there or it simply can't happen
Quote from: 'duggee27' pid='27893' dateline='1378895991'big deal about getting data faster
That has absolutely
nothing to do with it.
This is all about data, and moving it. Have a read of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_data for a start.
And look at it like any other fluid. Water. Electricity. Fuel. Even people. Retail use is
never the big picture. Not in usage volume or in benefit to the nation. Retail is just how the infrastructure is paid for... by overcharging us till we're bled dry. So it can be subsidised for the people who create the jobs, y'know?
Do you really think our highways were built for pleasant drives in the country? No. They were built because we depend on them for our very existence. Do you think water storages are for us to have a glass of water? Nup. Domestic consumption is around 7% of the total. 66% is agriculture, the rest industry and commerce. Did you know 22% of Victoria's water goes to produce electricity and gas?
Again, infrastructure, and the costs of building it, are
all about the big picture, not about our convenience. And like it or not, we do live in a global economy, which is powering ahead as fast as it can. Do we really want to stuff the country for future generations by pennypinching over something so critical?
Quote from: 'duggee27' pid='27893' dateline='1378895991'big deal about getting data faster... your brain wont compute / digest this info as quick.
are our young ones smarter than us cause they grew up with this technology
many other areas to be more beneficial to all
:angel::taunt:
lol, they don't need to be. They have cash registered to tell them how much change to give back and they still can't get it right.
QuoteDo we really want to stuff the country for future generations by pennypinching over something so critical?
I would rather put that statement in the context of Education, Health, Apprenticeships and job creation instead of supercharging the internet.
Lets face it in another few decades there will probably be a wifi type network that will bounce off satellites without the need of thousands of kilometres of optical cable buried all over Australia.
Just think back a few years ago when all we had was 1.44 modems and now we have wifi internet and NONE of this was funded by the government (Me and You)
We have old people dying alone, Kids that are badly educated, a shortage of skilled workers and a full time job is a rarity these days.
Time for a reality check, 53 billion of taxpayers money would be far more valuable spent elsewhere :ok:
lol, they don't need to be. They have cash registered to tell them how much change to give back and they still can't get it right.
here , here , lacey . I totally agree ,, kel ,,
Quote from: 'trout' pid='27969' dateline='1378973461'We have old people dying alone, Kids that are badly educated, a shortage of skilled workers and a full time job is a rarity these days.
ALL of which is reason to support doing this job right, once and for all. Where do you think the money goes to pay for all this?
Wages. Australian-made cables, concrete, steel, etc. Hardly any of it, in big-picture terms, is for imported gear.
As for education and skills, why do you think we do so badly on both? There is no opportunity in this country, precisely
because we lack the infrastructure. So our best people have to leave to get anywhere, because they can't do it at home.
I know more than a few extremely brilliant people. Geniuses in fact. And every last one of them no longer resides in Australia. Why? Because we suck, that's why.
The NBN may not fix us sucking. But thinking that band-aids are better than life-saving surgery, well, that's the whole problem right there.
I haven't signed it. I baulked when I was asked for my phone number. I'd happily sign a written petition.
I heard the guy on abc newsradio this arvo.
Is this even capable of being tabled in parliament, fulvio?
QuoteIs this even capable of being tabled in parliament, fulvio?
I consider it should be tabled in Parliament, Written on dunny rolls and used in the parliamentary Privies :ok::dance2:
Sorry Fulvio I admire you as a collector and you have a great sense of humour, But on this issue I Totally disagree with you Mate :ok:
I am happy with my Telstra Broadband it is quick and does everything I require
NBN so what I won't get this where I live
I'd prefer this forum be about coins not politics
I wonder how people got on before computers, the internet and broadband.
Me thinks people of today are becoming lazy due to the lack of activity of reading, counting and finding things out for them selves rather than siting at a keyboard and having a machine do it all for you.
Sorry, I do use the keyboard and a computer for record keeping etc as the device can do many monotaneous things whereas ones brain needs a rest.
$43BILLION for high speed talk fest link is a load of bunkham. I saw a roll of fibre optics cable being laid today and on the drum, it read Product Of japan. So much for creating jobs in Australia.
If they ever knock on my door to see if I want to be connected, they will be told in no uncertain terms where they can shoeve it.
Quote from: 'runway' pid='27982' dateline='1378986581'I'd prefer this forum be about coins not politics
This issue should not
BE about politics. It was a no-brainer from the start, and should have had bipartisan support.
However, since our beloved Dubya-clone now thinks he has a mandate, he's going to dismantle it for political gain, and the price will be paid by everyone in the country for decades to come, even if he gets the bums rush in a few years time.
IF the opposition is strong enough however, maybe, just maybe, they won't gut it to pay for some of the porkbarrelling this mob are grandmasters at.
Oh, and Runway? See up there where it says
"Chin Wag"? Nothing in here is about coins.
Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.
My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).
Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28009' dateline='1378996434'Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.
My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).
Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.
I'd love faster internet but I agree 100% with everything you've said here. If there's a commercial need for the sorts of speeds the Labor plan was offering then a COMMERCIAL company would have installed it. I am sick of my tax dollars being spend on infrastructure of the types that governments and public servants shouldn't be sticking their noses into.
As a disclaimer here I worked for several years in a government department that was responsible for various forms of industrial assistance. I saw so much wastage in there because public servants and politicians have NO IDEA about commercial reality. The idea that these sorts of people handle our tax dollars makes me sick to my stomach. Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28016' dateline='1379022458'Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28009' dateline='1378996434'Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.
My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).
Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.
I'd love faster internet but I agree 100% with everything you've said here. If there's a commercial need for the sorts of speeds the Labor plan was offering then a COMMERCIAL company would have installed it. I am sick of my tax dollars being spend on infrastructure of the types that governments and public servants shouldn't be sticking their noses into.
As a disclaimer here I worked for several years in a government department that was responsible for various forms of industrial assistance. I saw so much wastage in there because public servants and politicians have NO IDEA about commercial reality. The idea that these sorts of people handle our tax dollars makes me sick to my stomach. Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.
:agreed:
Common sense seems to be the correct answer.!!!
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28016' dateline='1379022458'Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.
Disclaimer: I worked for the commonwealth, both collecting and disbursing taxes. I also saw immense waste. Towards the end I was assigned a project to track usage of our fleet of commonwealth cars. Once I'd built the system and collected data from the first 250 vehicles, I got reassigned, the project was killed and buried, and a decree came down that everything would now be done in Canberra, and no further projects would be handled at state level. Why? I'm not at liberty to say, but if what I found were in the commercial world, heads would have rolled.
The problem with governments, all governments, is systemic and it makes no difference what they're doing. Whether its building a bridge or running a school or collecting trash, the rot is well and truly entrenched. If it could be excised, the savings would easily pay for a dozen NBN's. But that's never going to happen. And hasn't privatisation been a glowing success? We now pay more for less in
every area, including those Mark mentioned as governmental responsibilities.
Regardless, this matter is not going to sink or swim on the basis of our deliberations here. A majority of the population are against FTTN. The Libs will ignore that sentiment, because they are inherently arrogant, and have repeatedly proven it.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/breaking-news/turnbull-brushes-aside-record-nbn-petition/story-fni0xqi4-1226717898111
"Mr Turnbull replied: "Wasn't there an election recently at which nbn policy was a key issue?"". Arrogance, see? No conception of why they actually won, and why it does not give them a mandate to kill this.
Still, nothing will change for at least a year, so at the very least those areas already started, and probably those scheduled to start in the next year WILL at least get built properly. And of course greenfields sites will too from now on, because everyone realises its the right thing to do. So that once again means we'll have a two tier ballsup, with your address determining how well you do, just like with all Mark's examples. Which is par for the course for everything here, isn't it? :(
If you ask the question whether people prefer Labor's fast NBN or the Coalition's slower NBN, people will of course say Labor's NBN is better and preferred. But ask them to front up with the cash to pay for it ($5,000 to extend FTTN to the home for each household who wants FTTH), I think you'll find most people would be satisfied with the cheaper FTTN.
Fulvio, I am not sure where you live, but if it is in a suburban area, did you know that you can have the FTTN extended to your home so that you can get 1000 mbps downloads, but this will cost you personally $5,000 out of your own pocket. Are you still keen on the FTTH now, or would you prefer taxpayers to subsidise it for you?
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28061' dateline='1379041956'would you prefer taxpayers to subsidise it for you?
I'm MORE than happy with my cable, thank you very much. And our area will be one of the last to get whichever scheme ends up being built. So I don't care personally.
However, the fact is that the second-rate scheme will cost us double and saddle us with crap for decades.
The copper network is stuffed. Has been for years. 20 years ago when I wanted two extra phone lines, Telstra spent $40,000 putting in a second 80-pair because half of the existing cable was out of commission. That has only gotten worse, because of lack of maintenance.
FTTN needs POWERED boxes on every street corner. Which have to be built, maintained, and powered. Estimates are it will take an extra power station, burning coal of course, to power them.
The claimed speeds for FTTN are a pipe dream. ADSL speeds and throughput are the best they can hope for, on a good day. And that goes down with distance and condition of the copper.
In every single way, FTTN is crap. It is at best a stop-gap, and everyone who has rolled it out has since had to redo it properly. At double the cost.
This idiotic plan is like building a one-way freeway, then having to redo it years later at a far higher cost than doing it right in the first place.
Oh wait.. they already did that, didn't they? :P
Certainly a lot of good points being raised and the weight of opinion seems to be against the petition.
I'm quite happy with my current broadband plan but one point being raised is that the general population should not be funding the $5000 needed to connect NBN to a residence. If I decided to go down the NBN path then I wouldn't have the expectation of others funding it for me. If I receive a better product I expect to pay for it.
Like all telecommunication plans the broadband/NBN plans overlap and are hard to compare but my current plan is $79/month reduced to $59/month as a bundle for 50 Gb of which I use 10Gb. If I want NBN I'm looking at something like $100/month and an additional $20 if I want to "superboost" it to 100 mbps. So potentially I'm up for an extra $60/month or $720/year but will be using no extra downloads.
If NBN is going to be around for even 10 years then I've paid an additional $7,200 which would largely repay the $5000 the government puts up front for the installation. The alternative is that I stay with my current broadband in which case I contribute nothing extra rolling the NBN out to the "nodes" and that then becomes a burden on the taxpayer.
Probably a bit of a simplistic analysis but I'm of the view the government is only putting the money up front and will recoup most through higher fees. I have no doubt the NBN fees will go up once it becomes the norm or, alternatively, the other broadband plans will increase in costs to encourage more onto the NBN plans.
Could be wrong, but I thought Telstra had the NBN contract but since the election the Telstra share price has actually gone up about 6 cents so the financial community doesn't seem too worried about the new government winding it back.
Quote from: 'Steveqld' pid='28083' dateline='1379061395'The alternative is that I stay with my current broadband
That was never meant to be an option. Telstra was being paid $11 billion of that money to decommission their copper and HFC.
The reason of course is that they are outdated and a nightmare to maintain, so everything was to be replaced with fibre.
As for pricing, the wholesale price was fixed, so that every provider had the exact same price everywhere across the country. And the reason for that was the games Telstra was playing. Charging competitors extra or locking them out entirely.
Retail prices have a lot of factors built into them of course. But once the fibre network is in place, it is no longer one of those factors. Plus, as technology advances over time, it can very easily be plugged into the network, future-proofing it in a way copper can never be.
Oh, and as for Telstra's share price, of course its gone up. Telstra and Foxtel are the big winners in the second-rate network. Why do you think Murdoch threw his weight behind Abbott? He stands to gain billions out of this, as does Telstra, which is already renegotiating their deal.
As always, if you want the truth, follow the money and see who's snouts are in the trough.
QuoteAs always, if you want the truth, follow the money and see who's snouts are in the trough.
This has ALWAYS been the case and as long as the Bastards keep their snouts out of yours and MY pocket I will be reasonably happy :ok:
you have to realise that most "Political" decisions are NOT financially viable because they are playing with OUR money and NOT their own :dodgy:
I must admit I wasn't too fussed with the change of plans. But the copper network is surely cactus, there are still some pit covers with PMG on them!
In regard to FTTN does it sit alongside the existing copper network? Or does it replace the copper between the exchange and the fridge on my street corner?
I am a taxpayer living in a rural area and have ADSL it does the job for me I have no cable options nor ADSL2
Rollout of NBN will be done by whatever government is in power just think ourselves lucky we have internet at all I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me :(
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='28089' dateline='1379068123'In regard to FTTN does it sit alongside the existing copper network? Or does it replace the copper between the exchange and the fridge on my street corner?
OK, lets try and do a quickie Dummy's Guide...
First up, ALL the trunks are already fibre. Have been for a long time. So from the point of origin all the way across the oceans to the exchange down the road, its already blazingly fast. Has to be to handle the bandwidth, which is growing astronomically each year.
FTTP extends that fibre to your place. Its all glass, no electronics. Which means even in a major disaster, say a flood for example, it keeps working. FTTP also makes any existing copper or HFC redundant, and it gets decommissioned and presumably sold for scrap.
FTTN chops that off at the knees. They build new boxes at the corner, and terminate the fibre there. The last bit from the box to your place is the existing copper, which is limited to ADSL speeds. The box has to be big enough to terminate the fibre, convert the signal from light to a 50V current and feed it down the wires. Which takes a heap of gear and a bigger heap of power. And makes it susceptible to damage and degradation. Since the existing copper runs from telstra pillars, it will need to be relocated into the new boxes. No way the pillars can do the job.
The savings are almost all in wages. What you save on glass you spend on hardware, imported hardware at that. Oh, and you introduce a new ongoing and not insignificant maintenance and operating cost. Plus, copper is asymmetric. That is, there isn't the room in it for equal-size bandwidth in both directions. So the uplink is a tiny fraction of the downlink. Fine for cruising webpages, but pretty much useless for doing real work which requires data to move in both directions.
Then some years down the track, after its all finished and you discover its crap, it will need to be redone. By then of course, wages will have gone up, so it will cost more to do the job over. Plus all the interim hardware becomes so much scrap metal. The total cost will have more than doubled, and the country will have been uncompetitive for a generation.
But who cares? Abbott will be just another bad memory by then, and political gain is the only game that matters, right? Screw the future as long as you can make yourself look good short term.
Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me
Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me
Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?
I don't want to subsidise the internet of someone who chooses to live where they do. I am sure they don't want to pay all my additional expenses incurred from living in a city. So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'OK, lets try and do a quickie Dummy's Guide...
Thanks Fulvio I appreciate your effort. :angel:
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me
Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?
I don't want to subsidise the internet of someone who chooses to live where they do. I am sure they don't want to pay all my additional expenses incurred from living in a city. So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?
country WA has already "Subsidised" Via Drivers licence levies the stuff ups and infrastructure in Perth on occasion.
WA inc and the Northbridge tunnel come to mind :dash1:
If anyone wants/needs this service then they should dig into their own pockets and keep their thieving hands out of mine:close_tema:
Whether we're capital, rural or regional Australia I'm sure we will all be done over, just some more than others. (My cynicism also comes from working for the Government)
From what I read the coalition policy is dependent on taking over Telstra's copper cable between the node and premises. Telstra is unlikely to gift it to the Government so that will reduce the cost benefit from the FTTN option. Telstra seems to be in a great position hence possibly the increase in share price.
The most significant consideration for me is the amount I will pay for access to the internet, better performance isn't the highest priority. If I don't pay the "up to $5000" for the premises to node cable then I retain the copper cable. In that case my performance isn't going to change because I guess the transfer of can only occur as fast as the slowest link.
If I can remain on my current plan then "they" are getting nothing extra from me for the cost of their installing fibre optic cable to the node. If they abolish my current plan and make me go on an NBN plan then I will have 90Gb unused at the end of the month rather than 40Gb, no increased speed and it will cost me an extra $720 (approx.)/year.
Not looking good however the coalition policy does not alter the wireless or satellite options for rural or regional Australia so is of no consequence outside the capital cities.
All too much.
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?
Oh dear. This is unfortunately the way a lot of people think, and its just so wrong, on so many levels.
Firstly, we need the bush. Believe it or not, things happen out there that we actually need every single day. You know, like its where we grow the food you eat? That which doesn't come from some germ-ridden third-world country at least.
Secondly, not everyone can afford million-dollar homes in the city, or rents which exceed their incomes. Its not a choice when you only have one option.
Thirdly, even people who do live in the big smoke occasionally like to travel beyond the traffic jams.
Sorry, but either we're one nation, or a bunch of self-centred city states at war with each other. People in the bush already do it hard, and its not only fair to level the playing field, its also in our own best interest. The fewer reasons we give people to all move to the capital cities, the better.
Quote from: 'Steveqld' pid='28121' dateline='1379121724'Telstra is unlikely to gift it to the Government so that will reduce the cost benefit from the FTTN option. Telstra seems to be in a great position hence possibly the increase in share price.
Quite. Between them, Telstra and Murdoch will ensure we not only get to pay more than what the libs have said, but we'll continue to pay on an ongoing basis. Then eventually when we reach the point of having to rebuild it in a few years, we'll pay all over again.
This is all a con job, to stuff as much money as possible into their supporters pockets. Always was, always will be with this mob. Kinda sad the other lot are so bent on self-destruction that we find ourselves in this situation regularly.
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28181' dateline='1379146457'Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?
Oh dear. This is unfortunately the way a lot of people think, and its just so wrong, on so many levels.
Says you. I pay more than my fair share of tax and I am entitled to have an opinion on where it goes. Schools, fine. Hospitals, fine. Disability Care, fine. But subsidising internet for people in remote locations? I don't think so.
And by the way, I can assure you I do not live in a million dollar home. Not. Even. Close.
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28182' dateline='1379146896'Says you.
You're a smart, high-tech kinda guy. Here, read this:
http://nbnexplained.org/wordpress/technical-points/the-fttn-first-debate/
You really want to pay for one of these on every street corner?
(http://nbnexplained.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/photos-inside-telstras-nodes_2.jpg)
Quotenot everyone can afford million-dollar homes in the city, or rents which exceed their incomes
Mate if I was offered a mansion in the City for free I would knock it back.
I much prefer to live in the bush where your neighbours actually DO care, NO traffic noise and NO Nosey Busybodies within Cooee :yahoo:
Do I loose wifi connection sometimes YES
Do I get bad TV reception sometimes YES
Do storms do damage around the property that I have to repair myself YES
Are Australian farmers and Pastoralists considered some of the most efficient in the world YES
Is there less crime in the bush YES
Do I breath clean fresh air in the bush YES
Can I grow and produce my own Meat in the bush YES
Do we wave to policemen/women and know them by name in the Bush YES
Do we need to spend Billions of dollars just to have a faster internet connection in the bush
NO
To be honest Fulvio I don't want to pay for any of it. I am rabidly opposed to governments doing anything that commercial enterprises would do if it was profitable. I'd rather they (they being both sides of politics) kept their noses out of it and just cut taxes to companies and let them get on with the business of doing business. If someone can make a buck out of faster internet they'll install it and make money from it. If, as I suspect, it's not commercially viable in a big sparsely populated country like Australia then so be it. That's the price we pay for living in a great country. I for one, would take slow internet in Australia over living in the USA with blinding fast internet any day of the week. And that's coming from a (as you put it) a smart, high-tech kinda guy.
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28192' dateline='1379147836'opposed to governments doing anything that commercial enterprises would do if it was profitable.
And there you have it. Two differing world views.
One side says its all about money, and greed is good.
The other side knows that the greedy won't lift a finger for the common good unless forced to.
Lets privatise the post office. The police. Ambulances. Fire Brigades. The armed forces. I'm certain all would be very profitable businesses. Of course they won't provide services in marginal areas, but who cares, right? Let the invaders have the scrub, we'll stop them once they get near our capitals where people can afford to pay for services.
DOH!
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28207' dateline='1379151849'Lets privatise the post office. The police. Ambulances. Fire Brigades. The armed forces. I'm certain all would be very profitable businesses.
DOH!
Could we also make every road a toll road?
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='28213' dateline='1379152387'Could we also make every road a toll road?
Logical step. Oh, and put Wilson in charge of on-street parking too. Why should people be able to park outside their houses for free?
Now, how do we charge for the air people breathe?
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28216' dateline='1379152631'Quote from: 'r9453' pid='28213' dateline='1379152387'Could we also make every road a toll road?
Logical step. Oh, and put Wilson in charge of on-street parking too. Why should people be able to park outside their houses for free?
Now, how do we charge for the air people breathe?
I have far more important things to think about right now Fulvio Old Mate.
I'm off down the dirt road to have Beer and nibble's with my sister and Bro /in law , i'll be back in a few hours Mate :ok:
:scared: wasn't it doing the samething and around the same time last week when one had one's tooth pulled :)
Quote from: 'trout' pid='28219' dateline='1379153090'I'm off down the dirt road
Hmph. A road I probably subsidised. Bludger! Buy yer own! :diablo:
QuoteLets privatise the post office
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11067/gppo.jpg)
Fulvio,
What have you done now?
Entire NBN board resigns (http://www.smh.com.au/business/entire-nbn-board-resigns-20130922-2u835.html)
Heh. You were expecting something different? Ziggy screwed Telstra, and he's going to screw NBNco. I'm surprised they didn't all bail the moment his name came up.
This is going to turn into a massive disaster on every level I reckon. Inferior technology, and it will be handed over to the libs' mates in the telcos, who will do spectacularly well out of it, especially Tel$tra.
With the benefit of 20/20 hindsight of course, it should have been handled differently from day one. But its way too late to be crying over the spilt milk now.
Bring back Sol Trujillo I say; and screw it comprehensively.
Then we can start again.
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='29126' dateline='1379923047'Bring back Sol Trujillo I say; and screw it comprehensively.
Then we can start again.
Ah yes... good old Sol. A mate of mine used to work for him back in the states. When he heard they were putting him in charge of Tel$tra, he was extremely vocal about the guy. And not in a good way either.
Maybe we can make him PM and
really do the job properly?
Why bother; we already have Tony A. He will be as good/bad as Sol ever could be. Solomon T did not prove to have the wisdom of his namesake.
Jeff
Devil's advocate.
I got an Email from Nick Paine thanking me & telling me that there are over 200,000 signatures on the petition.
Quote from: 'interest' pid='29692' dateline='1380636502'there are over 200,000 signatures on the petition.
Which is a lot of people to ignore. But they will. So if the other mob can get their act together, this lot will be out next time round. Pity the damage will be done by then.
Received this update. Looks like there might just be a faint glimmer of hope yet:
It's working -- they're being inundated with calls. With just days until Malcolm Turnbull is likely to open up the NBN plan for cabinet consideration, the offices of senior ministers are starting to hear our message in support of the National Broadband Network.
And we know it's having an impact. After 200,000+ signatures, huge pressure on social media, and thousands of individual phone calls, the debate over the NBN continues dominate the front page of national newspapers like the Australian Financial Review and The Age.
The next few days are our chance to change the course of our future NBN -- in a big way. Malcolm Turnbull has already promised to be "technology agnostic", but the key will be whether the government opens up to public consultation in the review . If you haven't yet, can you please leave a message with a cabinet minister or your local MP today?
Here are some details. It takes just a few minutes -- and can be as simple as calling and saying that you support a fibre-to-the-home NBN and want the government to consult the public.
Ian MacFarlane - Minister for Industry: (07) 4632 4144
Bruce Billson - Minister for Small Business: (03) 9781 2333
Joe Hockey - Treasurer: (02) 9929 9822
Mathias Cormann - Minister for Finance: (08) 9325 4227
Barnaby Joyce - Minister for Agriculture: (02) 6761 3080
We need every Minister entering Cabinet to have heard our message for this to work: that the public won't accept anything but full consultation on the NBN, and that fibre-to-the-home is important to our nation's future.
This is how we keep the pressure on. It's how we eventually win our NBN back.
Thanks for your help.
Nick.
P.S. There's a heap of updates happening on our Facebook page -- so make sure you LIKE it by clicking here. Head over and let us know how contacting your MP went after you call.
No use stressing with NBN rollout and politics
Quote from: 'runway' pid='29767' dateline='1380730301'No use stressing with NBN rollout and politics
Now
that's a stupid thing to say.
Everything important is worth stressing about. Especially when politics gets involved, because then it gets corrupted and subverted for political gain. Case in point, the NBN is being screwed because it was implemented by the previous government, and the new mob are hell bent on undoing everything they did, not because its a good idea, but because the other side did it.
Its like one side starts building the Hume Freeway, and the other lot gets in and decides a dirt track will serve just as well. Screw the public and their objections. And you would say stop stressing about that too I suppose?
This is a fight that CAN be won. Its being won, albeit slowly, because a sizable chunk of the population care enough to speak out. It really IS the most important issue of the day. And it has nothing to do with politics, other than to stop a bunch of self-serving politicians buggering it up.
If the NBN is the "most important issue of the day" then something is really wrong with this country...........What happened to health, carbon tax, pensions and the high cost of power, gas etc.
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='29783' dateline='1380761545'What happened to health, carbon tax, pensions and the high cost of power, gas etc.
They're all related. From telemedicine to online government services, communications are at the core of all those things.
Face it, the world is changing. Rapidly. Those who don't keep up will get steamrollered, just like every technological revolution since the bronze age.
Ziggy's back!
Ziggy Switkowski to chair smaller NBN Co board (http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/ziggy-switkowski-to-chair-smaller-nbn-co-board-20131003-2uuzk.html)
NBN unlikely to meet Coalition's deadline (http://www.smh.com.au/it-pro/government-it/confidential-briefing-nbn-unlikely-to-meet-coalitions-deadline-20131128-hv3tp.html)
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='35687' dateline='1385692119' NBN unlikely to meet Coalition's deadline (http://www.smh.com.au/it-pro/government-it/confidential-briefing-nbn-unlikely-to-meet-coalitions-deadline-20131128-hv3tp.html)
QuoteOn Friday, Mr Turnbull dismissed the document during an interview with Channel Nine.
"This document is a) out of date, b) it is defending a failed project. It has no credibility, absolutely none," he said.
So lets see...
Option A, which they killed, involved stringing a bit of glass fibre from the exchange to your wall.
Option B, which they reckon is cheaper and faster, involves stringing a bit of glass to just short of your place, building a steel fridge, getting permission to plant it on the nature strip, run power to it, fill it with energy-hungry and fragile electronics, find a working piece of copper in the street, hooking that up to it, running the copper to your wall, and hoping you'll put up with the crap speed instead of going with some other alternative.
And this is supposed to take LESS time? Somebody's living in La-La-Land!
Oh yeah, and we'll do it all again in a couple years to *gasp* DOUBLE your speed! That's if nobody drives a truck over the cabinet of course, in which case you'll have NO internet.
Bleedin' wankers! :dodgy:
I can't decide if they are fibbing or just don't know what they are talking about.
All interested parties have their own agenda and a different "truth" about the issue.
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='35698' dateline='1385695377'I can't decide if they are fibbing or just don't know what they are talking about.
Probably both.
I saw a comment the other day that seemed to sum it up;
"Labour was going to do it once and do it right. The coalition is going to to it twice and do it wrong."
Of course, what we end up with may not be what they are promising now -politically driven processes have a habit of changing along the way. Of one thing I feel certain -the final cost will be much more than the estimates.
oh so true Jeff :(
When I worked for the Gov our motto was;
"There's never time to do it right, but there's always time to do it over and over and over."
Once when I returned from holidays, I had to re-do all the work that was done in my absence as every little bit of it had been done wrong.
QuoteOf one thing I feel certain -the final cost will be much more than the estimates.
I did say that above and have no reason to revise my opinion.
NBN: Malcolm Turnbull's 'faster, cheaper' roll-out falters (http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/nbn-malcolm-turnbulls-faster-cheaper-rollout-falters-20160228-gn5l0s.html)
Oops, quote "Since assuming responsibility for it, however, he has reframed its objectives to contain costs, arguing that providing optical fibre to everywhere but the most remote locations was foolish and that the network would best be constructed by a variety of means relevant to each location, including fibre, copper, satellite, and fibre-coaxial hybrid".
Is this mirroring what the rhetoric may have sounded like back in the mid 1800's when the Country embarked on it's first great infrastructure challenge, the railways? The only difference being, back then it was differing state Government agendas, this time it's differing Federal political ideologies. And look what we got back then, a mish mash of three non uniform rail gauges that has taken over 150 years to correct, and we're still not done. :dead_horse:
If you are going to do something do it right!
Don't take something and turn it into an even more complicated dogs breakfast (which will cost even more and be less reliable in the long run).
How stupid and short sighted - but that seems to be ingrained into our whole political system....
Our minimalist prime minister. What is the least amount of change I can get away with? NBN, tax reform...
You forgot the all important thing -trying to increase votes at the next election. (What is popular short term and don't worry about the long term.)
There are plenty of examples, even in recent times, of Prime Ministers making decisions that they thought were right and best for the country, even when polls suggested they may not be popular, and guess what...? The people actually respected them for that and didn't bite them at the voting booths.
There is an implication they underestimate us and patronise us. Well we did vote for them after all.