Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: coxspau on July 23, 2013, 10:17:27 AM

Title: Grading Thread
Post by: coxspau on July 23, 2013, 10:17:27 AM
Recognising that each of us how our own individual views on grading, does anyone see any value in starting a series of threads (based upon coin or grading type) which list images and suggested grades?

IMHO, grading is something that grows through experience, but such growth is enhanced when feedback is received from others.

The purpose of the thread would be to have people post images of coins which they believe align with particular grading and denomination.

I for one would be very interested to see the array of images that others would align to particular grades.

If this is something only I see value in, then I'm happy to close the thread off and seek advice when/where required.
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: trout on July 23, 2013, 10:47:07 AM
You are actually IN the grading thread with this post :ok:
Simply post a pic here and we take it from there :good: :)
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: coxspau on July 23, 2013, 11:46:31 AM
Good point Trout.

I guess what I was proposing was to have a number of images (from different members) all put under one topic such as "Penny - Fine". That way, members could share their thoughts and ideas about what they thought a penny graded fine would look like. Other topics would follow covering off different denominations and different grades.

Apologies as I'm not sure my prior explanation was a very clear.
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: markn on July 23, 2013, 11:51:05 AM
Quote from: 'coxspau' pid='22599' dateline='1374545791'Good point Trout.

I guess what I was proposing was to have a number of images (from different members) all put under one topic such as "Penny - Fine". That way, members could share their thoughts and ideas about what they thought a penny graded fine would look like. Other topics would follow covering off different denominations and different grades.

Apologies as I'm not sure my prior explanation was a very clear.

I think in principle that's a good idea.  In practice it's hard.  And the first reason I can think of is that coins imaged by different people using different equipment and different techniques can look completely different.  Even if they are technically the same grade.
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: Fordprefect on July 23, 2013, 01:54:24 PM
The eye appeal of image can alter your perception
of grade of coin quite a bit.
For example:-
1948 Penny
Single Cool White Compact Flouro Source.
(http://i679.photobucket.com/albums/vv160/ford_prefect/Australian%20Coin%20Forum/1948-Rev-Flouro_zps7ff1f3c6.jpg)
Nice enough coin but dull and lifeless.


Same coin using Dual LED light source.
(http://i679.photobucket.com/albums/vv160/ford_prefect/Australian%20Coin%20Forum/1948-Rev-LED_zps2933a23e.jpg)

Image Two would 9/10 times be graded higher than image One
but are the same coin.:angel:
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: coxspau on July 23, 2013, 02:45:56 PM
Both have solid points and the quality of the image will clearly have an impact. I guess my primary view was focused more on wear and surface condition. I am not devaluing toning (Fordprefect's images indicate the differences), just can't think up a good way of combating the different styles of coin photography that will result in different images.

If I am not mistaken, one point that Fordprefect's images do make is that, toning aside, surface wear and condition can still be assessed equally.
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: r9453 on August 19, 2013, 07:40:38 AM
The second image seems to hide some problems like the nick in the rim at 4 o'clock. Or does the first image make it look worse than it actually is?

So what are the grades of Fordprefect's 1948 Penny? And is the 'correct' grade somewhere between the two or more like one or the other of the images?
Title: RE: Grading Thread
Post by: ausjack on August 20, 2013, 06:22:30 AM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='22600' dateline='1374546065'
Quote from: 'coxspau' pid='22599' dateline='1374545791'Good point Trout.

I guess what I was proposing was to have a number of images (from different members) all put under one topic such as "Penny - Fine". That way, members could share their thoughts and ideas about what they thought a penny graded fine would look like. Other topics would follow covering off different denominations and different grades.

Apologies as I'm not sure my prior explanation was a very clear.

I think in principle that's a good idea.  In practice it's hard.  And the first reason I can think of is that coins imaged by different people using different equipment and different techniques can look completely different.  Even if they are technically the same grade.

yeah I agree or if someone Dr's a pic it makes it hard, doesn't it Mark..I still can't believe that post you put up about it :dodgy: