Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: Fulvio on June 26, 2013, 09:47:49 PM

Title: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 26, 2013, 09:47:49 PM
So as to not hijack the thin planchet penny thread, here's the promised pics of this 10¢:

2010 10¢ "Crochet Hook" cold shut
(http://goo.gl/MiQmg)(http://goo.gl/P2Dec)(http://goo.gl/uhry5)

I've got others, mostly $1, and all the more usual scythe-shaped spurs, but it may be a while before I can find them to photograph. No doubt others have examples to post though. :)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: robbiegal on June 26, 2013, 10:21:49 PM
cool
die clash?
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 26, 2013, 10:39:49 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='19506' dateline='1372251109'die clash?

Nope. Its actually a planchet flaw, not a die error.
You could (at least in theory) flake that piece off, leaving a cavity.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Goldseeker on June 26, 2013, 11:39:00 PM
Yep, I have several $1 coins that show the same "error"

I reported this in the now defunct Forum as a cold shunt and was blasted out od the paddock as they say.   The cold shunt was advised to me by a gent that had his own business and dealt with sheet metals.   He had the business for years.

I am glad someone other than me is calling this "error" a cold shunt.

I shall dig my $1 cold shunt errors out later and scan them for display.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 01:38:30 AM
Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='19511' dateline='1372255740'cold shunt

Umm, its "shut", as in door, not "shunt", as in train, Goldy. Lots of people make that mistake, and really cheese off the blacksmiths. :)

As for calling it an error, well, its not repeatable. Which is why I call them flaws, along with strikethroughs, fills, split planchets, brockages, etc etc etc.

Can't wait to see your pics, especially if you have some really cool ones. :)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 27, 2013, 07:31:59 AM
Cold shut it is.  I'm a bit perplexed as to how you can tell the difference between a planchet flaw and a "cold shut".  One is due to crap in the planchet, one is due to cold metal not being welded to hot metal.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 27, 2013, 08:52:25 AM
ya gotta be jokin, now there's another spanner in the works..can anyone think of any other errors or ways to get them..took a long time to pick up with this type
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Nevol on June 27, 2013, 11:19:29 AM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='19546' dateline='1372288945'ya gotta be jokin, now there's another spanner in the works..can anyone think of any other errors or ways to get them..took a long time to pick up with this type
I've been saving these for ages, I thought originally they were called 'cold shunt' then someone else referred to them as 'Rim Burrs' so now I know what they're really called, I'll have to see if I can find the little blighters.

I do have images, but they're all scans from before I got my cud'a'scope, and I can't even see the error on some of them, so they'll all need to be done again when I find them,  but not till the Tennis is over.  :angel:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 03:36:51 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19535' dateline='1372284119'I'm a bit perplexed as to how you can tell the difference between a planchet flaw and a "cold shut".  One is due to crap in the planchet, one is due to cold metal not being welded to hot metal.

Good question. The way I think of it, a cold shut is on the surface, and visible from day one. Its also all metal, so holds together pretty well. A planchet flaw is internal, and you don't know its there until it starts to let go and the coin peels, cracks or splits. If the crap were on the surface, it would get rolled out and either be long gone before the planchet was stamped, or appear as surface inclusions which would pit the surface. I do have some of the latter, and generally I try and help them go away, leaving the hole behind. I treat the resulting coin like any other strikethrough, though really it isn't.

Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='19546' dateline='1372288945'ya gotta be jokin, now there's another spanner in the works..can anyone think of any other errors or ways to get them..took a long time to pick up with this type

Hehe.. now ya see why I decided to differentiate between errors and flaws? :angel:

Errors have been pretty well exhaustively documented by now. There's only so many things you can do to a die without setting off alarm bells, even when QC is a joke.

Flaws, well, there must be hundreds of things that can go wrong, physically, metallurgically, chemically... You're dealing with some pretty heavy-duty industrial processes in really dirty environments, and even a minor event can end up a major flaw under a microscope.

That's what makes it so much fun I reckon. :yahoo:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 27, 2013, 03:44:38 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19560' dateline='1372313211'Good question. The way I think of it, a cold shut is on the surface, and visible from day one. Its also all metal, so holds together pretty well. A planchet flaw is internal, and you don't know its there until it starts to let go and the coin peels, cracks or splits. If the crap were on the surface, it would get rolled out and either be long gone before the planchet was stamped, or appear as surface inclusions which would pit the surface. I do have some of the latter, and generally I try and help them go away, leaving the hole behind. I treat the resulting coin like any other strikethrough, though really it isn't.

Interesting theory but planchet flaws are often quite visible on the surface.   I'd think that the edges of planchet flaws look quite different to cold shuts though.  Planchet flaws are quite ragged.  The cold shut, which is essentially a piece of cold metal being rolled into the coining metal probably wont end up looking like that.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 03:57:12 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19561' dateline='1372313678'planchet flaws are often quite visible on the surface.

Ever seen a peel on a new coin? I don't think I've ever found one younger than 15-20 years or so. Maybe they're there and just not visible until they start to lift off though. In which case the cud-o-scope™ might reveal all. :)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: purplepennyhunter on June 27, 2013, 04:07:18 PM
Alan Herbert describes this as "rolled in metal" suggesting a piece of coin metal fragment may find it's way back onto the strip as it's being rolled but doesn't end up adhering as suggested here. I like the pastry rolling analogy as I can associate with that. I have dabbled in welding in my time though.

This is an interesting thread.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 27, 2013, 04:16:09 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19568' dateline='1372314432'
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19561' dateline='1372313678'planchet flaws are often quite visible on the surface.

Ever seen a peel on a new coin? I don't think I've ever found one younger than 15-20 years or so. Maybe they're there and just not visible until they start to lift off though. In which case the cud-o-scope™ might reveal all. :)

I have UNC copper coins with peels visible on the surface yes.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 27, 2013, 04:20:24 PM
I'll have to keep an eye out be when noodling I have come across newer coins that look like road kill but now I'm thinking it might be something else waiting to happen..next time I find one I'll post a pic..looks sort of like they're crazing like paint does..very odd
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 04:39:23 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19573' dateline='1372315569'I have UNC copper coins with peels visible on the surface yes.

I didn't mean condition, I meant age. Not a lot of 2013 copper around that I've seen. :angel:

Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='19575' dateline='1372315824'sort of like they're crazing like paint does..very odd

I don't think I've seen an explanation for what that orange-peel is, AJ. I'm dying to know though...
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: enworb on June 27, 2013, 05:17:47 PM
If a coin is UNC and not handled roughly then how would age cause the flaw to appear?
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 27, 2013, 05:49:11 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19579' dateline='1372316963'I didn't mean condition, I meant age. Not a lot of 2013 copper around that I've seen. :angel:


OK.  Give me one logical reason why an old UNC coin would show planchet flaws and a new one wouldn't.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 27, 2013, 05:54:53 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19579' dateline='1372316963'I don't think I've seen an explanation for what that orange-peel is, AJ. I'm dying to know though...

Orange peel on copper coins is almost certainly due to excessive die use / wear.   I've matched so called "metal flow" and "orange peel" on various half pennies of the same year.  Clearly struck from the same worn dies in a similar state of die wear.  Identical orange peel and metal flow.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 06:45:09 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19593' dateline='1372321151'OK.  Give me one logical reason why an old UNC coin would show planchet flaws and a new one wouldn't.

I can't, because its not logical. But until we see these flaws in recent mintings, one has to conclude its age-related. Perhaps something changed in the manufacturing process to stop them happening. Perhaps there's a chemical reaction going on. Perhaps they're actually out there, and we simply haven't seen them. I don't know, but would like to.

Meanwhile, you've given me cause to document my splits. Starting with what's in this pile in front of me...

50¢ - 2x1971, 1973
20¢ - 1966, 1967, 1974, 1980
$1 - 1984x4, 1985x4, 1997, 1998x2
10¢ - 1974x2
$2 - 2004 (Extremely worn and corroded)

So the only 21st century (or current effigy) in the lot is one that's lived a stressful life, and even its 9 years old. I'm happy to be wrong about this, so if anyone has a new one, please show and tell.

Quote from: 'markn' pid='19594' dateline='1372321493'Orange peel on copper coins is almost certainly due to excessive die use / wear.   I've matched so called "metal flow" and "orange peel" on various half pennies of the same year.  Clearly struck from the same worn dies in a similar state of die wear.  Identical orange peel and metal flow.

So if I've got this straight, the die starts to deform with use, producing a rippled surface? Interesting. But wouldn't that take an awful lot of strikes, and show lots of other signs of wear? Apart from doubling, I can't say I've really noticed much else going on. Perhaps some dies are weaker than others, and more susceptible to deformation?
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Unicorn on June 27, 2013, 06:58:14 PM
Before I make a fool of myself for the 2nd time today, we're NOT talking about lamination flaws are we?
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 07:12:37 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='19609' dateline='1372325294'Before I make a fool of myself for the 2nd time today, we're NOT talking about lamination flaws are we?

Nope. Just comparing them because Mark asked a few posts back.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Unicorn on June 27, 2013, 09:25:25 PM
Thanks Fulvio, I'd dug out a 2008 $1 lamination and then thought, nah, they're not talking about that.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 27, 2013, 10:29:15 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='19628' dateline='1372334125'Thanks Fulvio, I'd dug out a 2008 $1 lamination and then thought, nah, they're not talking about that.

I'd like to see it though.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 28, 2013, 08:45:29 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19607' dateline='1372324509'I can't, because its not logical. But until we see these flaws in recent mintings, one has to conclude its age-related.

I don't think it's age related at all.  It's almost certainly process related.  If someone today was using the same poor processes the mints were using in the 50's and 60's I'm sure you'd see the same sort of errors.  That's no different to any other errors.  As quality control improves errors become scarcer.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 28, 2013, 08:53:34 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19607' dateline='1372324509'So if I've got this straight, the die starts to deform with use, producing a rippled surface? Interesting. But wouldn't that take an awful lot of strikes, and show lots of other signs of wear? Apart from doubling, I can't say I've really noticed much else going on. Perhaps some dies are weaker than others, and more susceptible to deformation?

Yes, that's exactly what I am saying. There's a thread here somewhere (that I can't find) with some identical looking 1964Y half pennies with the same die wear, orange peel, and metal flow.

Given that the PM was renowned for pushing dies to their limit it's not surprising that PM coins are the ones that show the most metal flow and orange peel.  Looking at the pattern of orange peel and metal flow I wonder if it's got something to do with the grain boundaries in the working dies.  If they were poorly aged during the heat treating process after being hubbed they could have a coarse (and brittle) micro structure.  As you strike more and a more coins perhaps there's localised wear and deformation at the grain boundaries of the die.  

Sorry if this is unclear but it's been a while since I did any metallurgy.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 28, 2013, 08:56:16 AM
shoot me down but the nickel could be the main thing here as old coins mark so much easier but these new one's can take a fair hit..not that I'd know, just what I've been told :winkextra:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: markn on June 28, 2013, 09:01:06 AM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='19653' dateline='1372375576'shoot me down but the nickel could be the main thing here as old coins mark so much easier but these new one's can take a fair hit..not that I'd know, just what I've been told :winkextra:

Improvements in processes is the most likely explanation.  Bronze one and two cent pieces always showed a lot fewer errors than half pennies and pennies despite being the same material.  The reason?  Processes used from production of the raw metal, rolling of strip, striking of blanks, and minting of the coins improved greatly from 1964 to 1966.  

Another example is to look at 1951PL half pennies and the Perth minted coins of the same year.  I've seen lots of PM 1951 half penny errors and hardly any London minted coins.  And they are the same material.  Explanation?  The Royal Mint was just doing things a lot better than the Perth mint.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 28, 2013, 09:03:28 AM
thanks Big M :mocking: I'm still learning so it's all good mate :good:

so it's more those roughians like trout that seem to be the problem :winkextra:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Unicorn on June 28, 2013, 09:12:31 AM
QuoteI'd like to see it though.

Here she is Fulvio ....

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11067/2008_lam.jpg)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 28, 2013, 09:15:46 AM
:good:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Robster on June 28, 2013, 09:25:42 AM
Great lamination Unicorn, if I ever get through the pre-decimals I look forward to the "new" coins.!! :angel:
Title: RE: maybe a 2013 mint set error
Post by: Nevol on June 28, 2013, 11:53:18 AM
Fulvio, Do the cold shuts always have the curled bit at the narrow end or would/could this be one?

From memory, nearly all the ones I have are like this, maybe only a couple with the curl.

50c 2005 CG Obv Cold Shut @ 6k
(http://i42.tinypic.com/2hx0vm9.jpg)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Nevol on June 28, 2013, 02:06:27 PM
These are what I believe, are the majority of my other Cold Shut coins that I can find.  I have more 50c Rev ones, but their whereabouts elude me at present.

$1 1984 Obv Cold Shut @ 4-5k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/11984ObvColdShut4-5k.jpg)

$2 2003 Obv Cold Shut @ 4-5.30k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/22003ObvColdShut4-530k.jpg)

$2 2006 Obv Cold Shut @ 11-12k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/22006ObvColdShut11-12k.jpg)

10c 2006 Rev Cold Shut @ 6k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/10c2006RevColdShut6k.jpg)

10c 2006 Rev Cold Shut @ 7k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/10c2006RevColdShut7k.jpg)

5c 1988 Obv Cold Shut @ 11k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/5c1988ObvColdShut11k.jpg)

5c 2001 Rev Cold Shut @ 12 - 1.30k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/5c2001RevColdShut12-130k.jpg)

5c 2006 Rev Cold Shut @ 12.30k.jpg
(http://i1112.photobucket.com/albums/k497/the_duchesse/My%20Error%20Coin%20Pictures/All%20Cold%20Shut%20Errors/5c2006RevColdShut1230k.jpg)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: ausjack on June 28, 2013, 02:30:38 PM
they look sort of like a tear..very funny and nice pic's Nevol :good:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 28, 2013, 02:41:56 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='19651' dateline='1372375414'Sorry if this is unclear but it's been a while since I did any metallurgy.

No, its crystal clear. And makes a lot of sense too. Thanks.

OK, I'll change my stance now, especially after seeing that lovely 2008 $1. Clearly while the processes have improved, there is still the occasional oopsie. :dodgy:

Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='19689' dateline='1372386198'Fulvio, Do the cold shuts always have the curled bit at the narrow end or would/could this be one?

Nope. they're almost always just like the one in your pic.

Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='19718' dateline='1372394187'5c 1988 Obv Cold Shut @ 11k.jpg

I especially like that one. Looks like a tail. Critter must be hiding on the Rev, eh?
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Unicorn on June 28, 2013, 03:04:50 PM
Quotethat lovely 2008 $1

While the topic is still hot, a couple more ....

2005 Dancing Man

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11067/2005_lam.jpg)

2006 MOR

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11067/2006_lam.jpg)
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on June 28, 2013, 05:47:35 PM
Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='19738' dateline='1372397690'While the topic is still hot, a couple more ....

OK, rub it in, why don't ya.. lovely coins though.. What was your address again? :diablo:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on July 20, 2013, 09:38:07 PM
Since having a discussion with Goldy, and slobbering all over a couple of lovely lamination flaws, I've been wondering about something..

Are ALL planchet flaws actually Cold Shuts?

There are a number of different types of metal defects, but to me it seems most of them don't apply to the rolled alloys our coins are made from. Shrinkage, Gas Porosity, Inclusions and Metallurgical Defects are more applicable to castings than rolled metals, whereas the rolling process itself appears to have a tendency to promote cold shuts.

If this theory is correct, then the different types of flaws, ranging from rim flakes to tears across the face of a coin to sections falling out to planchet splits, are all about the size and placement of the shut in relation to the planchet stamped through it. As with cuds and cracks, which vary from minute to colossal, its just a matter of degree.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: trout on July 20, 2013, 09:49:57 PM
From what I can understand is that Gold is one of the only metals that can be "Rolled" without any perceptible defects as it is a relatively soft metal.
Once you start using the same process with harder metals , ANY defect or dent in the ingot to be rolled will be transferred to the sheet when rolled .
The planchet peels could be simply a bit of metal that was folded over in the rolling process and ended up not unlike the way puff pastry is produced :ok:
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: JeffH on October 24, 2013, 07:17:05 AM
I'm thinking this could be a cold shut. Looks like a planchet flaw anyway -not PMD?
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10055/Cold_shut.jpg)
Taken with my digital microscope; now mounted on my new stand.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Robster on October 24, 2013, 08:03:57 AM
pics look great.!!
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: Fulvio on October 24, 2013, 02:45:22 PM
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='32055' dateline='1382561225'I'm thinking this could be a cold shut.

Yup. Definitely not PMD.

As I said a while ago, I've come to the conclusion that planchet flaws are all cold shuts anyway. The different looks are just a matter of how the pieces align. Whether its a long rip or a section that falls out, as this is, its all basically the same.

Your pic also clearly shows the parallel stripes that show up on a lot of this vintage. I think those stripes are a surface indication of flaws underneath. When those flaws come to the surface, they always seem to line up along the stripes. Perhaps the metal is folded in a wave, and the stripes are the tops of those waves? Also why does this only seem to happen with coins from this era? A difference in the planchet materials or manufacture? Or perhaps the stripes are an indication of stresses as the layers begin to separate, and that takes many years? If the latter, we may see the effect on younger coins in future.

It would be interesting to be able to see a cross-section.
Title: RE: Cold Shuts
Post by: JeffH on October 24, 2013, 04:17:05 PM
I would think that stripes are because planchet stock is rolled to thickness uni-directionally.