Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: MattGold on May 11, 2013, 08:42:55 AM

Title: Your Opinion
Post by: MattGold on May 11, 2013, 08:42:55 AM
(http://i44.tinypic.com/244txee.jpg)
(http://i40.tinypic.com/4dvew.jpg)

What would you guys grade this as?

Should I of had the image a little smaller as well?

Matt
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: enworb on May 11, 2013, 12:56:56 PM
Image looks perfect to me.

Obv: VF
Rev: gF-aVF

Overall aVF maybe VF
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: trout on May 11, 2013, 02:31:45 PM
I'm going to go with Fine , Cleaned with this one :ok:
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: accumulator on May 11, 2013, 02:31:52 PM
I agree with Enworb on grading, Nice doubling on the reverse too.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: enworb on May 11, 2013, 04:41:26 PM
Fine and cleaned? What makes you give it such a low grade considering all the detail remaining and what makes you think its cleaned?
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: trout on May 11, 2013, 04:53:50 PM
Quote from: 'enworb' pid='14428' dateline='1368256286'Fine and cleaned? What makes you give it such a low grade considering all the detail remaining and what makes you think its cleaned?
Not that much detail on the reverse except for the Grass, the roo and emu are worn down and the "advance Australia" is barely legible.
On the obverse there are 6 pearls but the rest of the coin is worn and marked up quite badly.
As for the cleaned attribution;
The unnatural color is a perfect indication that this has been dipped.
In hand this coin would probably have a "soapy" texture to touch :ok:
A 79 year old silver coin with this much wear simply shouldn't be as evenly shiny as this.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: Robster on May 11, 2013, 05:02:31 PM
Are all the legends doubled or am I mistaken.??
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: trout on May 11, 2013, 05:16:37 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='14430' dateline='1368257030'
Quote from: 'enworb' pid='14428' dateline='1368256286'Fine and cleaned? What makes you give it such a low grade considering all the detail remaining and what makes you think its cleaned?
Not that much detail on the reverse except for the Grass, the roo and emu are worn down and the "advance Australia" is barely legible.
On the obverse there are 6 pearls but the rest of the coin is worn and marked up quite badly.
As for the cleaned attribution;
The unnatural color is a perfect indication that this has been dipped.
In hand this coin would probably have a "soapy" texture to touch :ok:
A 79 year old silver coin with this much wear simply shouldn't be as evenly shiny as this.

My apologies to the OP I should have gone into more detail when I offered my opinion :blush:
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: MattGold on May 11, 2013, 05:53:08 PM
Thanks for the feedback all!!!!!

Are there any other ways to find out if it's been cleaned?

What do you mean by soapy texture feel to it? feels like the other silvers that I have to me.

I will have to take a look at the doubling on the letters but I can't get close enough with my magnifier, I've noticed since I've been using this scanner that I can see more doubling on a few other coins too, I guess my question is can scanners make it look like numbers and letters are doubled??

Full of questions today:idea:

Matt
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: accumulator on May 11, 2013, 08:23:27 PM
If it's been cleaned it will feel a bit like it's been lightly oiled sort of thing, another way of telling if it is cleaned is under magnification you'll see very fine scratches all runny parallel with each other,mainly in the open fields.

BTW i don't think it's cleaned but i've been known to be wrong about cleaned coins in the past.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: Fulvio on May 12, 2013, 03:31:50 AM
The feel is not a good indicator. When I de-gunk a coin, I hit it with RP7, then give it a good rinse in hot soapy water. They feel no different to any other coin.

Best indicator are the scratches. Even a tissue will leave fine scratches on the fields. Really obvious at 10x, just rotate it under a strong light and you can't miss the flashes of light.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: trout on May 12, 2013, 08:20:31 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='14485' dateline='1368295310'The feel is not a good indicator. When I de-gunk a coin, I hit it with RP7, then give it a good rinse in hot soapy water. They feel no different to any other coin.

Best indicator are the scratches. Even a tissue will leave fine scratches on the fields. Really obvious at 10x, just rotate it under a strong light and you can't miss the flashes of light.

I was referring to dipped coins, this leaves no scratches
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: MattGold on May 12, 2013, 10:20:26 AM
Is there a difference between the tiny scratches made from tissue/cloth and the tiny scratches made from a few years out in circulation?

Wouldn't there be coins out there that have not been cleaned but have similar scratch marks of those cleaned?

Matt
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: Mister T on May 12, 2013, 11:37:10 AM
Cleaning scratches might all be in the same direction I think.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: MattGold on May 12, 2013, 11:51:22 AM
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='14511' dateline='1368324430'Cleaning scratches might all be in the same direction I think.

Yeh I spose they would, unless the person was a careless cleaner that just went to town lol

Matt
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: Fulvio on May 12, 2013, 08:09:53 PM
Hard to describe, but there's sort of a newness and uniformity to cleaning scratches. Worn coins tend not to look the same at all.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: wwwww on May 13, 2013, 11:41:07 PM
Scratches that occur during circulation have smooth edges due to filling (oils, dirt, etc) - this is probably that newness/oldness thing Fulvio describes, but after a dip the scratches become sharp (as it removes the oils, dirt, etc) giving a look of a freshly brushed up coin. Cleaning hairlines are not necessarily very regular, in fact most of the time the opposite is true.

For this reason it can often be impossible to conclude that hairlines on a coin from circulation are not from cleaning. After all, if someone gets a greasy coin back from the butcher and wipes it between his shirt, does it get considered cleaned?

The rule of thumb is that if the surface damage is excessive for the grading, it is considered cleaned. If it is consistent with the grade level, it's considered original.

The 1934 shilling has certainly had a dip, it should still slab but only at around the VF30 level which is technically a good Fine but it'll probably get graded higher here for the band detail.
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: r9453 on May 23, 2013, 02:31:49 PM
If its Sellys it works:
(http://users.tpg.com.au/r9453//Selleys%20RP7.jpg)
:acute:
Title: RE: Your Opinion
Post by: Fulvio on May 24, 2013, 04:34:11 AM
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='15935' dateline='1369285309'If its Sellys it works: :acute:

I've got one of those... Its the rare "50g more" variety, in G-aVG condition with a few rust spots, and precious little propellant left. I'm actually tempted to cut it open and bottle the contents. ;)